"We find that research from prestigious institutions spreads more quickly and completely than work of similar quality originating from less prestigious institutions ... structural inequality in shaping the spread of ideas in science." https://t.co/DPgI3UL6
RT @CT_Bergstrom: Ideas also spread through non-meritocratic social processes like prestige. Since faculty move from high prestige graduate…
RT @CT_Bergstrom: Ideas also spread through non-meritocratic social processes like prestige. Since faculty move from high prestige graduate…
RT @CT_Bergstrom: Ideas also spread through non-meritocratic social processes like prestige. Since faculty move from high prestige graduate…
RT @CT_Bergstrom: Ideas also spread through non-meritocratic social processes like prestige. Since faculty move from high prestige graduate…
RT @FaithfullJohn: Lots of interesting stuff in this thread 👇
RT @CT_Bergstrom: Ideas also spread through non-meritocratic social processes like prestige. Since faculty move from high prestige graduate…
RT @CT_Bergstrom: Ideas also spread through non-meritocratic social processes like prestige. Since faculty move from high prestige graduate…
It's (only) about institutional prestige! Research from prestigious institutions spreads more quickly and thoroughly than work of similar quality originating from less prestigious institutions. 🤔https://t.co/2hubysXhBn
RT @CT_Bergstrom: Ideas also spread through non-meritocratic social processes like prestige. Since faculty move from high prestige graduate…
RT @CT_Bergstrom: Ideas also spread through non-meritocratic social processes like prestige. Since faculty move from high prestige graduate…
RT @CT_Bergstrom: Ideas also spread through non-meritocratic social processes like prestige. Since faculty move from high prestige graduate…
RT @CT_Bergstrom: Ideas also spread through non-meritocratic social processes like prestige. Since faculty move from high prestige graduate…
RT @CT_Bergstrom: Ideas also spread through non-meritocratic social processes like prestige. Since faculty move from high prestige graduate…
RT @CT_Bergstrom: Ideas also spread through non-meritocratic social processes like prestige. Since faculty move from high prestige graduate…
RT @CT_Bergstrom: Ideas also spread through non-meritocratic social processes like prestige. Since faculty move from high prestige graduate…
RT @CT_Bergstrom: Ideas also spread through non-meritocratic social processes like prestige. Since faculty move from high prestige graduate…
RT @DaniSBassett: Work from @alliecmorgan: Prestige drives epistemic inequality in the diffusion of scientific ideas. "Our results ... prov…
RT @DaniSBassett: Work from @alliecmorgan: Prestige drives epistemic inequality in the diffusion of scientific ideas. "Our results ... prov…
RT @DaniSBassett: Work from @alliecmorgan: Prestige drives epistemic inequality in the diffusion of scientific ideas. "Our results ... prov…
RT @DaniSBassett: Work from @alliecmorgan: Prestige drives epistemic inequality in the diffusion of scientific ideas. "Our results ... prov…
RT @DaniSBassett: Work from @alliecmorgan: Prestige drives epistemic inequality in the diffusion of scientific ideas. "Our results ... prov…
RT @DaniSBassett: Work from @alliecmorgan: Prestige drives epistemic inequality in the diffusion of scientific ideas. "Our results ... prov…
RT @DaniSBassett: Work from @alliecmorgan: Prestige drives epistemic inequality in the diffusion of scientific ideas. "Our results ... prov…
RT @DaniSBassett: Work from @alliecmorgan: Prestige drives epistemic inequality in the diffusion of scientific ideas. "Our results ... prov…
RT @DaniSBassett: Work from @alliecmorgan: Prestige drives epistemic inequality in the diffusion of scientific ideas. "Our results ... prov…
RT @DaniSBassett: Work from @alliecmorgan: Prestige drives epistemic inequality in the diffusion of scientific ideas. "Our results ... prov…
RT @DaniSBassett: Work from @alliecmorgan: Prestige drives epistemic inequality in the diffusion of scientific ideas. "Our results ... prov…
RT @DaniSBassett: Work from @alliecmorgan: Prestige drives epistemic inequality in the diffusion of scientific ideas. "Our results ... prov…
Work from @alliecmorgan: Prestige drives epistemic inequality in the diffusion of scientific ideas. "Our results ... provide a theoretical lower bound for the impact of structural inequality in shaping the spread of ideas in science." https://t.co/vvRmeme5
@ben_golub @sfiscience You can find the whole paper here! https://t.co/EmMIFBeicq That figure was a simulation study to explore the consequences of ideas spreading only by faculty hiring. Idea "quality" is just its transmissibility across the hiring networ
RT @Asian4Diversity: A look at mirro-tocracy in STEM. Selective high schools like TJ are part of the wider system that creates and perpetua…
Fascinating
A look at mirro-tocracy in STEM. Selective high schools like TJ are part of the wider system that creates and perpetuates these non-merit-based structural inequities, and therefore must be part of the solution as well. #TJAAG #RedefiningMerit @TJAlumniAG h
@daviddesancho @BlasBenito @brembs It's clear that the success of both scientists and scientific ideas is largely influenced by non-meritocratic factors, e.g. https://t.co/IoU2xNKSHR https://t.co/HVoILNeMCZ https://t.co/AVtU278Frl https://t.co/4oJcOb9g
RT @aaronclauset: Dr. @alliecmorgan's dissertation covered three significant contributions, all fascinating. Chapter 1, "Prestige drives ep…
RT @aaronclauset: Dr. @alliecmorgan's dissertation covered three significant contributions, all fascinating. Chapter 1, "Prestige drives ep…
Dr. @alliecmorgan's dissertation covered three significant contributions, all fascinating. Chapter 1, "Prestige drives epistemic inequality in the diffusion of scientific ideas" 2/5 https://t.co/EmMIFAWGNQ
RT @Raamana_: @DanHandwerker I 100% agree with you Dan - I am not against giving out more awards. And in fact, I personally don't give awar…
RT @Raamana_: Very insightful study on how "prestige drives epistemic inequality in the diffusion of scientific ideas" Matthew effect, no…
Ref 1: https://t.co/OtfZE3GaWD
@jweisber @scott_bot smokes this is interesting! Thanks for sharing. For more check out @alliecmorgan and @aaronclauset's work on simulating networks and epistemic effects. https://t.co/Riwgol397A
@tdverstynen Another issue with trying to count twitter advocacy is relatively disproportionate reach for some privileged folks for the same ideas and similar level of effort.. attention circles on Twitter often (not always) reflect typical academic circle
@DanHandwerker I 100% agree with you Dan - I am not against giving out more awards. And in fact, I personally don't give awards that weight at all, given how biased the system is throughout the pipeline, as well as the presence of "rich clubs" and nominati
RT @Raamana_: Very insightful study on how "prestige drives epistemic inequality in the diffusion of scientific ideas" Matthew effect, no…
Very insightful study on how "prestige drives epistemic inequality in the diffusion of scientific ideas" Matthew effect, not for individual researchers, but for departments, and in addition to the "halo effect". https://t.co/PCDwrK8VRN #phdchat #Academic
RT @JacksonmMatt: @causalinf Raises interesting questions about the efficiency of scientific production. Other data on hiring, productivity…
@causalinf Raises interesting questions about the efficiency of scientific production. Other data on hiring, productivity, and the visibility of publications in computer science by @aaronclauset - https://t.co/td2qJqfZ2w and https://t.co/2hvaw4oxw5 - she
@timelfen @allergyPhD @SciTechProf @familyunequal @cwellmon also work by @aaronclauset on idea networks and hiring networks. https://t.co/DVJnstuzRh
RT @geomblog: @johnregehr @lhochstein @vj_chidambaram @CSrankings @emeryberger @aaronclauset 1. On the effect of rankings in hiring - https…
RT @geomblog: @johnregehr @lhochstein @vj_chidambaram @CSrankings @emeryberger @aaronclauset 1. On the effect of rankings in hiring - https…
RT @geomblog: @johnregehr @lhochstein @vj_chidambaram @CSrankings @emeryberger @aaronclauset 1. On the effect of rankings in hiring - https…
RT @geomblog: @johnregehr @lhochstein @vj_chidambaram @CSrankings @emeryberger @aaronclauset 1. On the effect of rankings in hiring - https…
RT @geomblog: @johnregehr @lhochstein @vj_chidambaram @CSrankings @emeryberger @aaronclauset 1. On the effect of rankings in hiring - https…
@johnregehr @lhochstein @vj_chidambaram @CSrankings @emeryberger @aaronclauset 1. On the effect of rankings in hiring - https://t.co/dBrGQVPPyS 2. On the dissemination of ideas in academic networks https://t.co/9eVNJLQbtT
@DonIngber The university's prestige of idea's author(s) also plays a role, unfortunately: https://t.co/YxGtHhYWKu
RT @josephenderson: @jamacintosh @TheTattooedProf “Who are the scholars we've lost to austerity?” I think of this often, especially in ter…
RT @josephenderson: @jamacintosh @TheTattooedProf “Who are the scholars we've lost to austerity?” I think of this often, especially in ter…
RT @josephenderson: @jamacintosh @TheTattooedProf “Who are the scholars we've lost to austerity?” I think of this often, especially in ter…
Prestige drives epistemic inequality in the diffusion of scientific ideas https://t.co/GpNztbGLzq
Prestige drives epistemic inequality in the diffusion of scientific ideas https://t.co/v9QB9ydbJH https://t.co/ckNISnM5Ik
RT @juicethemodeler: A revealing thread about how institutional prestige directs science. Pitching even top-quality ideas is an uphill batt…
Also this: “We find that research from prestigious institutions spreads more quickly and completely than work of similar quality originating from less prestigious institutions.” https://t.co/Bh86DiSSAm
RT @juliancardenasx: Las ideas científicas se propagan más en otras universidades cuando vienen de una universidad de prestigio debido a la…
RT @juliancardenasx: Las ideas científicas se propagan más en otras universidades cuando vienen de una universidad de prestigio debido a la…
Pareto again @LadyAAmado
Las ideas científicas se propagan más en otras universidades cuando vienen de una universidad de prestigio debido a la red de profesores de las universidades de élite. Pero no son necesariamente ideas de mejor calidad. https://t.co/R7WDYZwHlE https://t.co
RT @GaetanBurgio: This fascinating paper shows that prestige is a major driver in #academia for 1) Faculty hiring 2) diffusion of scientifi…
@rw_hass previous work by the authors have documented/quantified "epistemic inequality" (good ideas from less prestigious places need to be x% better than equivalent idea from more prestigious place to spread as far): https://t.co/ceyXuUa489
RT @GaetanBurgio: This fascinating paper shows that prestige is a major driver in #academia for 1) Faculty hiring 2) diffusion of scientifi…
RT @GaetanBurgio: This fascinating paper shows that prestige is a major driver in #academia for 1) Faculty hiring 2) diffusion of scientifi…
RT @GaetanBurgio: This fascinating paper shows that prestige is a major driver in #academia for 1) Faculty hiring 2) diffusion of scientifi…
RT @GaetanBurgio: This fascinating paper shows that prestige is a major driver in #academia for 1) Faculty hiring 2) diffusion of scientifi…
RT @GaetanBurgio: This fascinating paper shows that prestige is a major driver in #academia for 1) Faculty hiring 2) diffusion of scientifi…
RT @GaetanBurgio: This fascinating paper shows that prestige is a major driver in #academia for 1) Faculty hiring 2) diffusion of scientifi…
RT @GaetanBurgio: This fascinating paper shows that prestige is a major driver in #academia for 1) Faculty hiring 2) diffusion of scientifi…
RT @GaetanBurgio: This fascinating paper shows that prestige is a major driver in #academia for 1) Faculty hiring 2) diffusion of scientifi…
RT @GaetanBurgio: This fascinating paper shows that prestige is a major driver in #academia for 1) Faculty hiring 2) diffusion of scientifi…
RT @GaetanBurgio: This fascinating paper shows that prestige is a major driver in #academia for 1) Faculty hiring 2) diffusion of scientifi…
RT @GaetanBurgio: This fascinating paper shows that prestige is a major driver in #academia for 1) Faculty hiring 2) diffusion of scientifi…
Interesantes datos🤔🤔
RT @GaetanBurgio: This fascinating paper shows that prestige is a major driver in #academia for 1) Faculty hiring 2) diffusion of scientifi…
RT @GaetanBurgio: This fascinating paper shows that prestige is a major driver in #academia for 1) Faculty hiring 2) diffusion of scientifi…
RT @GaetanBurgio: This fascinating paper shows that prestige is a major driver in #academia for 1) Faculty hiring 2) diffusion of scientifi…
RT @aaronclauset: Hypothesis: university prestige shapes the flow of scientists, which determines which scientific ideas get worked on, whe…
RT @aaronclauset: Hypothesis: university prestige shapes the flow of scientists, which determines which scientific ideas get worked on, whe…
RT @Undercoverhist: Now apply this to a highly hierarchical discipline in recruitment, publications, promotion, professional societies mana…
RT @aaronclauset: Hypothesis: university prestige shapes the flow of scientists, which determines which scientific ideas get worked on, whe…
RT @Undercoverhist: Now apply this to a highly hierarchical discipline in recruitment, publications, promotion, professional societies mana…
RT @Undercoverhist: Now apply this to a highly hierarchical discipline in recruitment, publications, promotion, professional societies mana…
RT @Undercoverhist: Now apply this to a highly hierarchical discipline in recruitment, publications, promotion, professional societies mana…
RT @Undercoverhist: Now apply this to a highly hierarchical discipline in recruitment, publications, promotion, professional societies mana…
RT @Undercoverhist: Now apply this to a highly hierarchical discipline in recruitment, publications, promotion, professional societies mana…
RT @aaronclauset: Hypothesis: university prestige shapes the flow of scientists, which determines which scientific ideas get worked on, whe…
RT @Undercoverhist: Now apply this to a highly hierarchical discipline in recruitment, publications, promotion, professional societies mana…
RT @Undercoverhist: Now apply this to a highly hierarchical discipline in recruitment, publications, promotion, professional societies mana…
RT @aaronclauset: Hypothesis: university prestige shapes the flow of scientists, which determines which scientific ideas get worked on, whe…
Now apply this to a highly hierarchical discipline in recruitment, publications, promotion, professional societies management and prizes