@cercopithekevin @primalpoly @AryaVolkan @DanLarremore @aaronclauset @alliecmorgan @laberge_nick It's not as far-fetched as you might think, given the diverse array of life outcomes that show negligible influence from family background in twin/adoption stu
@willigula @primalpoly @aaronclauset @alliecmorgan @laberge_nick @DanLarremore Twin & adoption studies indicate that lifetime income is 50% genetically influenced, and the other half is random. https://t.co/uQOM4IZiXj
@michaelgarfield @primalpoly @DanLarremore @aaronclauset @alliecmorgan @laberge_nick @JacksonmMatt The heritability of lifetime income in several studies is roughly 50%, with no detectable effect from family background. Social networking is, in any case,
@IgneousSigil @natilemeijer @stonkpol @cvaldary I would say that's a completely quixotic endeavour in a world where parents are allowed to raise their own children, but actually, parental SES just doesn't matter very much to most life outcomes. https://t.
@IlariSulasalmi @jarikuikanmaki @jussikniemela En ole tietoinen tutkimuksista tai aineistoista jotka vastaisivat näihin. Tämä tulopaperi Suomesta on, mutta siinäkään ei voitu tutkia muutosta: https://t.co/5ForVl4MFM
@RichardHanania You might have come across this paper already, but in case you haven't... https://t.co/hL36rINK5A
@kalle_leppala @mikakorte Esitit 0 tutkimusta. Esitä edes 1. Tulot: geenit määräävät puolet, sattuma toisen puolet, perhe ja muu ympäristö eivät lainkaan. Sama tulos Suomessa ja muualla (USA, Austr.: 10 %). https://t.co/3qpjEa5sfi
This 2019 study of Finnish twins by @artahy et al found the total genetic influence on lifetime earnings was 54% in men & 41% in women, with no evidence of family environmental influence! That's a remarkable finding which I think deserves more attentio
Järisyttävä tulos tästä artikkelista. Pitäisi tutkia enempi miten näihin tuloksiin on suhtauduttu.
@teemu_p_peltola @Puolustusvoimat Pienituloisuus ei periydy lainkaan vanhemmilta, ainoastaan biovanhemmilta. Geenit määräävät puolet, sattuma toisen puolet, perhe ja muu ympäristö eivät lainkaan. Miksi vahvan markan politiikan aiheuttama lama olisi periyty
Tuloksena yhteiskunta, jossa tulot ja lopulta varallisuusasema määräytyvät entistä ylisukupolvisemmin. Lasten vanhemmat näkevät paljon vaivaa, jotta jälkipolville jää varallisuutta. Osa ehkä säätiöitetään. Resursseja hukkaan, kun etsitään porsaanreikiä.
@Eon717 @Bugless_Double @aretieare https://t.co/8IzDwKMN5m Using twenty years of earnings data on Finnish twins, we find that about 40% of the variance of women’s and little more than half of men’s lifetime labour earnings are linked to genetic factors. T
@tsaarimaa Perhe, koulu ja muu ympäristö selittävät yhteensä 9 % elinkaarituloista Usassa, Pmaissa 0 %. 3/4 tuloeroista (ei elinkaari?) on perheiden sisäisiä, 1/4 välisiä (lähinnä geeneistä ja sattumasta). Osoite voi kertoa paljon geeneistä => jäätelyk
@anssiramela @kone_isto @keronen @annakontula Voitko heittää lähdettä, että voin katsoa, mitä tekijöitä on kontrolloitu? Esim. tämän mukaan Suomessa geenit on suurin merkittävä tekijä tulotasolle. https://t.co/asoQghHDcg
@OskuTorro @rotosherranen Tässä kohtuullisen pätevää kotimaista kaksostutkimista aiheesta https://t.co/zg2sqZl3AE
双生児による生涯賃金の遺伝分析 男性だとACEモデルにおけるC(共有環境分散/家族間分散)が負の推定値になってしまう。したがってADEモデルが選ばれる。興味深い。 https://t.co/VCiSLjmGha
RT @Russwarne: Finding more pieces of DNA that correlate with income was not very surprising. For decades, heritability studies have shown…
RT @Russwarne: Finding more pieces of DNA that correlate with income was not very surprising. For decades, heritability studies have shown…
"Approximately half of men’s lifetime labour earnings are linked to genetic factors." https://t.co/k1uBzqTz8d
RT @NoahCarl90: @ewanbirney Twin studies typically find that the heritability of income in Western countries is 40-45%: https://t.co/O4FBwC…
RT @NoahCarl90: @ewanbirney Twin studies typically find that the heritability of income in Western countries is 40-45%: https://t.co/O4FBwC…
RT @NoahCarl90: @ewanbirney Twin studies typically find that the heritability of income in Western countries is 40-45%: https://t.co/O4FBwC…
Don't understand the fuss around the recent income GWAS. Twin studies already showed SES is heritable, a lot more heritable than the found SNP heritability. The existence of racism and ignorance doesn't mean we shouldn't do science, on the contrary, proper
Finding more pieces of DNA that correlate with income was not very surprising. For decades, heritability studies have shown that income is partially influenced by genes. #psychology https://t.co/DkHgVKQWS0
@RuneLinding @ewanbirney Also apropos: https://t.co/S6Smu1IwGQ
RT @KirkegaardEmil: Meta analysis of family studies here finds about 50 % when measured well. https://t.co/JTtQJCZoI6
@SPeitsch Wrong. Genes play a much bigger role in determining what you will earn from employment over your lifetime than any single environmental factor. From the abstract: "[Approximately] half of men’s lifetime labour earnings are linked to genetic fa
RT @KirkegaardEmil: Why say "barely" when the truth is that it's about 50% the variance that's due to genetics, and little due to family en…
RT @KirkegaardEmil: Meta analysis of family studies here finds about 50 % when measured well. https://t.co/JTtQJCZoI6
RT @KirkegaardEmil: Meta analysis of family studies here finds about 50 % when measured well. https://t.co/JTtQJCZoI6
RT @KirkegaardEmil: Why say "barely" when the truth is that it's about 50% the variance that's due to genetics, and little due to family en…
RT @KirkegaardEmil: Meta analysis of family studies here finds about 50 % when measured well. https://t.co/JTtQJCZoI6
RT @KirkegaardEmil: Why say "barely" when the truth is that it's about 50% the variance that's due to genetics, and little due to family en…
RT @KirkegaardEmil: Why say "barely" when the truth is that it's about 50% the variance that's due to genetics, and little due to family en…
Meta analysis of family studies here finds about 50 % when measured well. https://t.co/JTtQJCZoI6
Why say "barely" when the truth is that it's about 50% the variance that's due to genetics, and little due to family environment. Granted of course that one measures it properly (over many years, register data). https://t.co/JTtQJCZoI6
RT @NoahCarl90: @ewanbirney Twin studies typically find that the heritability of income in Western countries is 40-45%: https://t.co/O4FBwC…
RT @NoahCarl90: @ewanbirney Twin studies typically find that the heritability of income in Western countries is 40-45%: https://t.co/O4FBwC…
RT @NoahCarl90: @ewanbirney Twin studies typically find that the heritability of income in Western countries is 40-45%: https://t.co/O4FBwC…
@ewanbirney Twin studies typically find that the heritability of income in Western countries is 40-45%: https://t.co/O4FBwCQiIB https://t.co/nK14qARYMK
@deemmmssss @jasonrileywsj @benshapiro @WSJopinion @ManhattanInst @FoxNews Genes play a much bigger role in determining what you will earn from employment over your lifetime than any single environmental factor. From the abstract: "[Approximately] half o
@Xenos_RIFS @KevinRCampbell @EPoe187 @sullydish You're having trouble keeping up. The topic we're more broadly discussing is the efficacy of our social interventions when so many outcomes are dominantly influenced by genes. Half of men’s lifetime labour e
RT @pitiklinov: Heredabilidad de los ingresos a lo largo de la vida: “encontramos que alrededor del 40% de la varianza de los ingresos de…
RT @pitiklinov: Heredabilidad de los ingresos a lo largo de la vida: “encontramos que alrededor del 40% de la varianza de los ingresos de…
RT @pitiklinov: Heredabilidad de los ingresos a lo largo de la vida: “encontramos que alrededor del 40% de la varianza de los ingresos de…
RT @pitiklinov: Heredabilidad de los ingresos a lo largo de la vida: “encontramos que alrededor del 40% de la varianza de los ingresos de…
RT @Oantastlig: @HenrikSundstrom Ja, faktum är att en stor Finsk studie precis visade att över hälften av skillnaden (i variansen) i mäns i…
RT @Oantastlig: @HenrikSundstrom Ja, faktum är att en stor Finsk studie precis visade att över hälften av skillnaden (i variansen) i mäns i…
RT @pitiklinov: Heredabilidad de los ingresos a lo largo de la vida: “encontramos que alrededor del 40% de la varianza de los ingresos de…
RT @pitiklinov: Heredabilidad de los ingresos a lo largo de la vida: “encontramos que alrededor del 40% de la varianza de los ingresos de…
Lifetime Earnings Are 40-50% Heritable https://t.co/AMMBhKbMxE comm: https://t.co/gE6SbiGfEQ
RT @pitiklinov: Heredabilidad de los ingresos a lo largo de la vida: “encontramos que alrededor del 40% de la varianza de los ingresos de…
RT @pitiklinov: Heredabilidad de los ingresos a lo largo de la vida: “encontramos que alrededor del 40% de la varianza de los ingresos de…
Heredabilidad de los ingresos a lo largo de la vida: “encontramos que alrededor del 40% de la varianza de los ingresos de las mujeres y algo más de la mitad de la de los hombres está ligada a factores genéticos. La contribución del ambiente compartido es
RT @a_centrism: Genes play a much bigger role in determining what you will earn from employment over your lifetime than any single environm…
Lifetime Earnings is 40-50% Heritage, Study Finds. #study #mustread #financialindependence #income #financialfreedom https://t.co/oqSDLpQg9u
Lifetime Earnings Are 40-50% Heritable: https://t.co/wWNiyQGSz6 Comments: https://t.co/8tgmvjuvur
Lifetime Earnings Are 40-50% Heritable https://t.co/BlcMUhHch3
Lifetime Earnings Are 40-50% Heritable https://t.co/8zzKRfKx2h
Lifetime Earnings Are 40-50% Heritable https://t.co/cJCwl3xIKA (cmts https://t.co/uBF1gN0AOo)
Lifetime Earnings Are 40-50% Heritable L: https://t.co/GzMe5LodLK C: https://t.co/0LWX2QUBqW
RT @pitiklinov: Alrededor de la mitad de las diferencias individuales en los ingresos a lo largo de la vida en Finlandia es atribuible a fa…
@JussiPullinen Tulojen osalta pätee: perimä vaikuttaa niihin 50 %, ympäristö (ml. vanhempien sosio-ekonominen asema) 0 % ja sattuma 50 %. Sinäkin laskit s-e-taustan ja perimän yhteen, joten lukusi ei kerro, kummasta on kyse (osa on perimää; veikkaan, ettei
@JussiPullinen Riippuu siitä, paljonko syntyvyys nousisi euroa kohden ja miten nettomaksavia näin syntyvät olisivat. Perimä kun määrää tuloista 50 %, ympäristö 0 %; loput on sattumaa. (Progressiivisen) päivähoitomaksun poisto voisi tukea nettomaksajasyntyv
@PhilWMagness @williamcmay Oh... but there is more. What should be done to all this research? 😏 https://t.co/OkCTj6FdiE
@MoilanenAnne @MarttaManna @okmfi @STM_Uutiset @valtioneuvosto @AnttiRinnepj @Demarit Hyvinvointivaltio vaatii, että saadaan lisää nettoveronmaksajia, ja se periytyy. Suomessa, Ruotsissa, Norjassa, Australiassa ja ~USAssa ympäristö (perhe ym.) ei vaikuta t
@nntaleb There's a mountain of evidence in the field of behavioral genetics that says otherwise; performance in many complex environments is highly heritable, an example being that lifetime income has a heritability of about 50%: https://t.co/qKTozhnvJr
@PSuurhasko @jmpentikainen Tuoreen suomalaistutkimuksen mukaan veronmaksukyky periytyy geneettisesti 50 % (loput sattumaa, perhe ei vaikuta) ja muut tutkimukset ovat saaneet saman muualla, joten hyvinvointivaltion tulevaisuus riippuu siitä, tekevätkö urava
@JohannaMuurinen @ivanpuopolo Suora linkki jutussa mainittuun tutkimukseen: https://t.co/k3F4SBC5a4
Erot ihmisten ansio- ja pääomatuloissa johtuvat suureksi osaksi perintötekijöistä eli geeneistä. Tämä herättää monia ajatuksia. https://t.co/fQQm9CzSTJ
RT @aivoAALTO: @KirstiLonka @rrenkone @AaltoUniversity @helsinkiuni @THLorg @minnahuoti https://t.co/K7Xe3CMp8N mukaan identtiset ♀️ tienas…
@KirstiLonka @rrenkone @AaltoUniversity @helsinkiuni @THLorg @minnahuoti https://t.co/K7Xe3CMp8N mukaan identtiset ♀️ tienasivat 0.06% ja ♂️ 2.7% enemmän kuin epäidenttiset. Eipä tunnu paljolta kun mm valintoihin vaikuttavaa kaksosten keskinäistä riippuvuu
RT @AmirSariaslan: Around half of the individual differences in lifetime earnings in Finland is attributed to heritable factors with neglig…
RT @AmirSariaslan: Around half of the individual differences in lifetime earnings in Finland is attributed to heritable factors with neglig…
RT @ValidScience: Interesting. Lifetime income is pretty heritable. Shared environment is negligible. I wonder how this squares with other…
RT @AmirSariaslan: Around half of the individual differences in lifetime earnings in Finland is attributed to heritable factors with neglig…
RT @AmirSariaslan: Around half of the individual differences in lifetime earnings in Finland is attributed to heritable factors with neglig…
Interesting. Lifetime income is pretty heritable. Shared environment is negligible. I wonder how this squares with other research. https://t.co/LR1NFkuToo
RT @DegenRolf: About half of individual differences in lifetime earnings are due to genetic factors, with classical nurture, the shared env…
@OsmoSoininvaara Myös USAssa, Ruotsissa, Norjassa ja Australiassa sama tulos: geenit selittävät puolet tuloista, ympäristö (yleensä perhe, asuinalue, kasvatus, koulu jne.) 0 % (USAssa 9 %), sattuma loput: Taulukko 1. Btw, sama yleensä saadaan älylle ja luo
RT @AmirSariaslan: Around half of the individual differences in lifetime earnings in Finland is attributed to heritable factors with neglig…
RT @UofLEcon: Interesting paper Table 1 provides a history of previous estimates on the effect of genetics on earnings. 40% of the variatio…
Interesting paper Table 1 provides a history of previous estimates on the effect of genetics on earnings. 40% of the variation in earning can be explained by genetics. Less than 15% from shared environment. This paper break the effect down for men & wo
RT @OriKatz3: מחקר המבוסס על תאומים בפינלנד (קישור בתגובות) העלה, בדומה לממצאים ממחקרים קודמים, שגנטיקה מסבירה כמחצית מהשונות בהכנסות לאורך…
@tsaarimaa @artahy @JohanssonEdvard @HelsinkiGSE Kannattaa lukea itse paperi eikä tuota julkaisualustan keskustelua https://t.co/D96wiDm55t
מחקר המבוסס על תאומים בפינלנד (קישור בתגובות) העלה, בדומה לממצאים ממחקרים קודמים, שגנטיקה מסבירה כמחצית מהשונות בהכנסות לאורך החיים, בעוד שהשפעת הסביבה המשותפת של התאומים היא זניחה. קישור: https://t.co/5n4A7BPZG3 https://t.co/AaALdc2kgs
@IlariSulasalmi @tsaarimaa @artahy @JohanssonEdvard @HelsinkiGSE Tuo linkki on Marginal Revolution University -nimiselle www-sivustolle, joka vain nostaa artikkelin esiin omalla sivullaan. Artikkeli on julkaistu täällä: https://t.co/Eql6Rlp47s
Study of Finnish twins (n~7000) by @artahy et al finds 40% of the difference in lifetime labour earnings is linked to genetic factors (for women—for men it’s just over half): https://t.co/mAYYymIQ8C https://t.co/h7CXh9TjKc
Для тих, хто не спить. Здається, шведські вчені наздоганяють британських. Аналізуючи фінансові успіхи моно- і дизиготних близнят, вони встановили, що доходи у жінок на 40% визначаються генетичними факторами, а у... https://t.co/QEVu7kQ33i
RT @DegenRolf: About half of individual differences in lifetime earnings are due to genetic factors, with classical nurture, the shared env…
RT @DegenRolf: About half of individual differences in lifetime earnings are due to genetic factors, with classical nurture, the shared env…
RT @DegenRolf: About half of individual differences in lifetime earnings are due to genetic factors, with classical nurture, the shared env…