@ocioar @AlexandrPerusio @Rationaliber @autocorrect2_0 @darwintojesus They literally studied animals for years and found evidence of empathy in certain creatures. https://t.co/mrpopufz6q. Even homosexual behavior in certain animals. How is that possible?
@ascameron_ @BornAgainMissy Animals do have a conscience and are capable of making moral decisions. You should really spend some time researching these opinions of yours instead of just making bald assertions with no evidence and just what you feel is rig
المصادر : https://t.co/Z5HpUloYj6 https://t.co/OaYBByK9M4.
@CarlosOsler2 @ZachyLucas @NotEvolution1 Since we have long witnessed it? We see animals exiled from their packs due to theft, we see advanced empathy and all the things that go along with morality. https://t.co/l5eoly0IRp.
@WNestor1983 @jdfranko Mira, hay cosas que no podemos aceptar o negar porque es difícil bajo nuestro sistema de creencias (y ciencia) comprobarlo, sin embargo, te dejo un artículo por si te interesa https://t.co/MpvkxVcjEQ
@RonaldEricMoor2 Poor, deluded man. Even many animals have a moral compass, and feel emotions such as love, grief, outrage and empathy. No god required. The risible, MANmade, cruel Biblical god came many hundreds of thousands of years too late on the sc
@The_Jaded_Geek @TheAmreld @DeusVult2727 @ssuddeth1 @MallardReborn @conditionalZep1 @ThomLately Animals are not amoral though. Moral behaviour has been observed in many species. https://t.co/6jCxxPdcPX.
@MetalicMariposa @babyshart88 @smashbaals As I said: stop trying to claim that animals don't have consciences, when you have produced zero evidence to support that claim. And since I already produced evidence that at least *some* animals DO have a moral
@MetalicMariposa @babyshart88 @smashbaals Also, you have not shown that animals don't have a conscience. In fact, the evidence says the opposite. https://t.co/Je7YtU009V https://t.co/uIze5BHALA
@HHankerson3021 @stoltussolus Just humans? What makes you think other species don’t have morals? So egotistical https://t.co/9vVqzQ4cFS.
@Emanuel66201297 @SheiiaTheRito @Lilith_Atheist https://t.co/rRzlAOgt5W I look forward to you turning over all the evidence showing how animals are capable of morale behaviour beyond food which is very simple minded. Maybe you should get your education fro
RT @PapaCornelius: @JohnQCitizen23 @Lilith_Atheist That's not true. https://t.co/1Tw6AFJXuy
@JohnQCitizen23 @Lilith_Atheist That's not true. https://t.co/1Tw6AFJXuy
@suziferg0806 @TheValuesVoter They understand across species that there is a natural law & natural justice, and can become quite distressed & even enraged when they see it occur. 3/https://t.co/Ytv9siQ6kG https://t.co/eXtNDBJnDW
@suziferg0806 @TheValuesVoter Animals in the wild can be ruthless & cruel, for survival; unkind to disabled among them who might hold them back. But they operate from a universal “law” that values fairness & compassion when basic needs have been me
@RussNRoses @NotEvolution1 No, it has been widely observed in numerous species: morality differs greatly between human societies, there is no fixed norm for right and wrong, thus it is just an arm of social behaviour https://t.co/1ig2JKkH1k.
@SpeedWatkins @SecularOutpost In other words, do you think animals can be moral subjects, even if they are not moral agents? And if so, how does that effect our understanding of moral ontology? https://t.co/tN1Ac1IIyc
@ButtCheeksMoses @Edward_TankX We aren’t. There is much evidence in the animal world of moral behaviours. https://t.co/37zhs7xh5n
@juansmith0123 @Kenneth32160759 @HAHazony @MattWalshBlog And here's an interesting study about morality in animals. It's not conclusive for me but it does seem highly plausible. https://t.co/jJbpfHNCrt.
@roseman419 @Vapyd0fficial @RicoKRS @fantasykingpin @Lilith_Atheist Millennia of philosophical study and debate around what’s best for the individual/the group and the balance between them. We aren’t the only species with morals. Even rats show altruism.
@outmawl @whisperingrrave morals exist outside of religion. in fact, even some animals could have morals, or at least, they act empathetically in a way that resembles morality https://t.co/wAlDt0XsIj.
@itssanman @God_damn_it_Lux Ive already given you my anecdote where it is the case. Care to be more specific on what exactly it is you want me to prove, and what does and doesnt constitute proof to you? How about this? https://t.co/RYBVuPEy6Y https://t.co
@tommy_koko3 @ScootyPuffSr99 @ClayCasper5 @crankycripchro1 @autocorrect2_0 …have shown the capacity for cooperation even when there’s no direct reward. https://t.co/QeKjoXgshb.
@Eyetin2floh @JesusTruth1 @BookOfRevelatio Bad faith request. No one claimed chimps are intellectually equal to humans but it’s obvious by studying them we evolved from a common ancestor. Morals aren’t some woo that a woo god hands out but an evolved trai
@larrygasch @wendelltalks It’s not the atheist job to justify anything. They aren’t making the God claim. We are a social species & like most vertebrates we have the capacity for empathy. We are not the only species with a sense of “morality” however c
@orna_verum @BrianNazarenus Some animals do have moral reasoning just not to the same level as human beings. I think the danger in not recognizing these traits in animals leads to an abuse of the natural world and the animals in it. https://t.co/1JqsJpNv
@uav_guy_79 @JohnFugelsang Animals have empathy. They think and feel. Animals also have shown morality. Research supports this. https://t.co/VXuZSZ59J3 https://t.co/17ZSfJEKOk.
@aigkenham @aigkenham I respect your well thought out questions about morality. My question as a non-believer is how you engage with observations of animals making moral (as far as we can tell) decisions? Thank you for your consideration. https://t.co
@AugustineParzi1 @Christ_With_Ken Ken might be shocked to learn we can observe moral codes in non-human animal species that likely far predates our specie’s existence. https://t.co/nDQ2Il6pqm
@drazzapaws @punk_razor @Buddy_TheWolf @JaredOpasm @WispStar @meekobby_ 1. False. Animals understand morality. 2. Non sequitur. Humans having their own brand of morality doesn't mean they both can't engage in harmless sexual escapades in which no party fee
@meatballrob2024 @paleochristcon Yeah there is, if you don't---you go to prison. Of course there are ethical systems in nature, try and attack a mother bear's cubs and see what happens. https://t.co/sU5QFzNss0.
@Leigh_Phillips @BarnardPhoebe @ZeynepinLE @jan_dutkiewicz The following studies don't count? https://t.co/VbdP2jb0Ad. https://t.co/XYhaE1gqb6
@deerwolfart A few studies on the subject of morality in non-humans. Animal Morality: What It Means and Why It Matters https://t.co/pPie1CBDJ1 Evolution of responses to (un)fairness https://t.co/cet7DHmBrF Third-party social evaluations of humans by mon
@Sovereignlove11 @Thedukeistheman @ArthurMooreIV @SecularOutpost 1) Why do you believe that no animals make moral judgments? The evidence suggests otherwise. 2) Humans ARE animals, and the evidence also suggests that our morality is a product of biologica
@babyboybuu No, but a lot of research suggests they do. My claim is, more so, that they can recognize that they are doing stuff out of “malice”. https://t.co/85LrxpA5g1.
@todollua @ghost_of_miri @venusianhunty Even before I read this study that's not true because we know for a fact that rats have morals due to their high intelligence so yea, other animals can have morals https://t.co/GpQ1gyPqJx.
@SklifosDergen @Skooma_Beast Und, übrigens, Tiere haben Bewusstsein und Moralität. https://t.co/pPie1CBDJ1
@Nate3722 @TakeThatDarwin @Rob_ThaBuilder @g0nPATRIOT @stillgray Except it has. We have observed it occur in other species. And considering you get your morality from a book that promotes fake, genocide, and slavery? You have no room to talk https://t.co/7
@ArchStanton007 @peta @elonmusk @Twitter No fish on the list (beginning) https://t.co/jPSzCIahDm
@TosinAwe1 @Luplow94 @Tmitch91082 @iamAtheistGirl I didn't realise Glenn Hoddle was quite as prolific.🤣 Is that the impossible 'creation' from Genesis I or the equally nonsensical one from Genesis II? Morality comes from us being a social species and isn'
@VbcApologetics @TheSoleWitness Ever seen elephants? Far better creatures than most Christians https://t.co/9OKXKhP63N https://t.co/ZMYNkDLohW https://t.co/fzEJbICn5z
@garylfrancione Lol 🤣 there you go again putting humans on a pedestal apart from nature. How on earth do you know whether or not pigs or any other animal do or don't make moral decisions? Sort of ironic how speciest you are. https://t.co/NG9PuupzLD.
@LukeSo20 @erichovind 1) Humans aren’t the only species that demonstrates morality. https://t.co/SxnCBDIAzD.
Honestly, James Corbett’s speech sounded more like a defence barrister trying to find reasons to acquit. It was useless. While for various reasons I don’t agree with @Sean_McDowell, he was far more convincing.
Back to this. Sean was an astonishingly good speaker for a novice, James Corbett was doomed even before he got to speak, but Sean is fundamentally wrong, inter alia because nonhuman animals exhibit morals https://t.co/kqC1HJDBYJ
Animals are not moral. Those claiming this have yet to prove their claims, and are paving the way for zoophilia. https://t.co/qCCwFWAUxV
@DariustheMede_ @peregrinus_AK @WTFudgicle @JTWhite_65 @TakeThatDarwin It’s almost like we’re also animals. It’s almost like morals are formed naturally https://t.co/ZMYNkDLohW
@CastoresRd @chaosotter @its_seanturner1 @johnpavlovitz Ok, this is an interesting paper with dozens of citations regarding non human animal morality. There are plenty of examples of an animal saving another, or even a human, of grief, comfort, justice, et
@yuuuoooool @DFWsCars @PXPARALLAX @Ghettobatt @N13lCl I never talked about intelligence. You talked about morality not existing in animals whereas it does. https://t.co/7OyK4YteR8
@ComeBackIggy @PalebloodO @justxseptit @Lylanthia @vasanthipanchak @LibertyCappy Morality has been found in animals. Their brains are simply not nearly as developed as ours and cannot think about those things. We simply had the highest brain capacity in th
Não sei se sabiam o que nos distingue dos outros animais, mas está em discussão! O que me choca, é um golfinho ou um bonobo, ter comportamentos morais mais elevados do que “condutores de animação turística” ou “drivers” de “tuk tuks” (marca registada)!
“beings who are moral subjects are entitled to enjoy positive opportunities for the flourishing of their moral capabilities, and that the thwarting of these capabilities entails a harm that cannot be fully explained in terms of hedonistic welfare.” https
@copsewoodRk @SteveTiger999 @ingersoll_bob @SpagFlying Then why do animals display ethical behavior? https://t.co/JBLA3gWRHt So you allow no space for ethical considerations to be a natural part of reality apart from some supernatural consideration? This
@NeutralTheist @dumbsushi @CapturingChrist That's simply not supported by the facts. There are lots of examples of altruistic actions in animals. You're pretending that you can get inside the heads of animals. https://t.co/W65k7Q9Sc8.
有很多研究吧?共情能力、公平感、利他行为等。鸟老鼠狗都都有,不用提更聪明的大象和灵长类。 比如https://t.co/wXoxBhHGHJ 你担忧的事情是“几乎没可能发生”;电影描述的和引起我反思的是“过去已经发生,现在正在发生,如果不够重视未来依然会反复发生”,所以是不同量级也无法比较的两个东西。
@PjBlackmoore @TheUnvirgin Treat others as you wish others to treat you - no more no less If one needs to look to holy books for morality, chances are they have none Even animals seem to have morality, from which bible do you think https://t.co/deE4hukQqN.
@OleDwyer @ArendvanDelft @jjvpeperstraten Christenen geloven in een door hun god gecreëerde rangorde tussen mens, dier en planten waarbij er vanuit gegaan wordt dat de mens bovenaan staat omdat enkel de mens "moraal" zou hebben. Dat is echter achterhaalde
@Wardiator @SirFoxFur @Conserberal @JrwJohn @BeatTheCult Why should there be "ought" in there? Religion is NOT a requirement for morality - Fact. Empirical evidence gathered so far suggests that some "non-human" animals do in fact behave morally. From whi
@denyyourtruth @NoHolyScripture “Some studies, for instance, have found that animals are sometimes willing to help others when there is no direct gain involved, or even a direct loss.” This seems to indicate empathy. https://t.co/2J6EFhwBo6
@PaultheAtheist @NoHolyScripture Evidently it is possible for animals to act morally, “Some studies, for instance, have found that animals are sometimes willing to help others when there is no direct gain involved, or even a direct loss.” https://t.co/2J6E
@ChippMccrea @NoHolyScripture Evidently so, “The empirical evidence gathered until now suggests that Rowlands may be on the right track and that some animals are indeed capable of behaving morally.” https://t.co/2J6EFhwBo6
@GthKarma @NoHolyScripture You have personally defined "morality" as a human centric thing and arguing against every point made. That's circual reasoning. Morality isn't "one thing". We define morality in social species as a way of identifying fairness a
Building on the work of @Susana_MonsO, Benz-Schwarzburg and Bremhorst, cultural animals may also be subject to an extra set of harms relating to the disruption of cultural capacities that are missed if we just focus on affective states. https://t.co/chz9r
@sonsoflight21 @irSkullBeard @WestDockWharf @Renevelation @Dlanorx @SlenderSkeptic @TakeThatDarwin @Ah_Science @dannjymac @totalibearian @SoftUzama @JesusIsKing67 @olla2nji @Edwyeen @Oluwalana54 You can found plenty of examples of animals acting morally, w
@AdaBlue11 Animals have subjective morality. https://t.co/HEm49xbOQJ
@ambimorph @RichardDawkins That gulf may not be as immense in many cases of social animals as Frans De Waal, Carl Safina, Balcombe, Rowlands, and others would argue. Moral agency is also highly contentious in metaethics, as a clear definition still hasn't
🦒🐰🐸🐥🐭🦊🐙🐌🦥🐴🐮🐳🦋 Biosemioticians and animal lovers! Consider this important P.S. to #WorldAnimalWelfareDay #WorldAnimalDay 🤓☝️ #ethics #Philosophy
RT @SpringerEthics: #animalday #WorldAnimalWelfareDay 🐾 #openaccess papers of interest Betraying Animals https://t.co/6Z7WU0bV2C Animal…
#animalday #WorldAnimalWelfareDay 🐾 #openaccess papers of interest Betraying Animals https://t.co/6Z7WU0bV2C Animal Morality: What It Means and Why It Matters https://t.co/Vw0wQaU7ux
RT @Midietacojea: @SvalexBCN @SmeRuiz Tu paradoja inventada: https://t.co/G9Jswi0qLg