@a_sator ganz im Unterschied zu früher sind konservative Soziologen heute rar, sehr gute Studie in den US dazu: https://t.co/b4SUs7RwOc
1️⃣Sosiologiassa yms tutkijoiden liberaali/konservatiivi suhde saattaa hyvinkin olla 14:1 Vaikka suhtautuisi mahdolliseen ”liberaaliharhaan” epäilevästi on valtava ero 8/ https://t.co/LQBprroDSX
1️⃣Sosiologiassa yms tutkijoiden liberaali/konservatiivi suhde saattaa hyvinkin olla 14:1 Vaikka suhtautuisi mahdolliseen ”liberaaliharhaan” epäilevästi on valtava ero 8/ https://t.co/LQBprro63p
1️⃣Sosiologiassa yms tutkijoiden liberaali/konservatiivi suhde saattaa hyvinkin olla 14:1 Vaikka suhtautuisi mahdolliseen ”liberaaliharhaan” epäilevästi on valtava ero 9/ https://t.co/LQBprro63p
😶Survey on 479 sociologists: "results […] can be understood by conceptualizing the field of sociology as an 'emotive community'. […]knowledge construction among sociologists appears removed […] from the Enlightenment ideals of rational inquiry […]." https:
#NoWay "We survey 479 sociologists (...) We find significant patterns in the data. Commitment to the field’s “moral mission,” preferred research paradigm, gender, and especially political orientation are all significant predictors of sociologists’ views."
@didaktiikki Tuossa on siis tutkimus tästä ilmiöstä. Toinen tutkimusraportti alan biasoitumisesta https://t.co/WDdY8RAVhO
RT @AcadFreedom: Les travaux de Horowitz et collègues sur les croyances des chercheurs en sciences sociales et leurs positions par rapport…
RT @AcadFreedom: Les travaux de Horowitz et collègues sur les croyances des chercheurs en sciences sociales et leurs positions par rapport…
Les travaux de Horowitz et collègues sur les croyances des chercheurs en sciences sociales et leurs positions par rapport au militantisme ont donné lieu à plusieurs articles : https://t.co/vqHkxAFb0E https://t.co/6Ei0Tl1Ztq https://t.co/IHwKrvLo7h
Moral Foundations Theory and Disciplinary Controversies https://t.co/irFGrcr9Tp
@shutupemoly @merci_ciao @jaypeasey @steveplotnicki @deonteleologist Here is a citation for "culture war" gender differences among sociologists: https://t.co/fELcxFhGey Here is one for general political leanings: https://t.co/oEOZOaiX8T One for censors
RT @thomastaussi: @tapiomaatta On tutkittu, että Yhdysvalloissa sosiologian alalla vallitsee vahvasti ideologinen konsensus alan yhteiskunn…
@tapiomaatta On tutkittu, että Yhdysvalloissa sosiologian alalla vallitsee vahvasti ideologinen konsensus alan yhteiskunnallisista missioista sen sijaan, että tutkimuksen tehtävänä oli pitkälti ymmärtää ja selittää maailmaa ilman arvokannanottoja. https://
@antiantioedipe @PetteriSihvonen @ivanpuopolo Tässä oli vielä laajempi vertaisarvioidussa journaalissa julkaistu katsaus sosiologian alan tutkijoiden poliittisista asenteista. Erityisen mielenkiintoista on se, että sosiologialla nähdään olevan poliittinen
En sociologie, il y a de bonnes raisons de penser que c'est le cas, cf. notamment ici : https://t.co/6Ei0Tl1Ztq
@KimmoJNieminen1 @Sukkola Ja tämä on minusta sitä Ukkolan kolumnissa mainittua väärinymmärrystä. Herne meni niin nopeasti nokkaan, ettei vaivaudutta pohtimaan voisiko pääkirjoituksessa olevan pointtia. Ihmistieteiden ideologisista yhteyksistä on kuitenkin
@didaktiikki Heh. En usko, että on olemassa sellaista todistusaineisto, joka voisi sinut vakuuttaa :D Sitten on toki myös tälläinen tutkimus sosiologeista. Horowitz on käsittääkseni tehnyt vastaavia myös antropologeista ja taloustieteilijöistä. https://t
RT @thomastaussi: Satojen sosiologian professorien haastattelussa paljastui, että 83% oli vasemmalla, (21% "radikaaleja!"). Yli puolet piti…
RT @thomastaussi: Satojen sosiologian professorien haastattelussa paljastui, että 83% oli vasemmalla, (21% "radikaaleja!"). Yli puolet piti…
RT @thomastaussi: Satojen sosiologian professorien haastattelussa paljastui, että 83% oli vasemmalla, (21% "radikaaleja!"). Yli puolet piti…
RT @thomastaussi: Satojen sosiologian professorien haastattelussa paljastui, että 83% oli vasemmalla, (21% "radikaaleja!"). Yli puolet piti…
RT @thomastaussi: Satojen sosiologian professorien haastattelussa paljastui, että 83% oli vasemmalla, (21% "radikaaleja!"). Yli puolet piti…
Satojen sosiologian professorien haastattelussa paljastui, että 83% oli vasemmalla, (21% "radikaaleja!"). Yli puolet pitivät sosiologiaa yhteiskunnallisena agendaliikkeenä. Tämän nähtiin vaikuttavan suuresti myös tutkimuskohteiden ja -teemojen valintaan. h
@PhilosophyExp Perhaps not "most", but many 🙃 https://t.co/6Ei0Tl1Ztq
@roderickgraham Part of the problem is that a fair number of social science researchers also dismiss hypotheses/results that do not fit their moral intuitions, and attempt to "understand [human phenomena] through politics". https://t.co/6Ei0Tl1Ztq
Triptych now! all those things are (I'd say *inevitably* ) coupled with (~delusions of grandeur~ oops, no) plans to transcend all forms of social oppression: ~S~ https://t.co/z266rqBdZR &ss: https://t.co/KeqH9dgD0K
@jurijfedorov This may be of interest: https://t.co/xyhAcQ6NQk
Mark Horowitz and co-authors tried to quantify this for sociology and found that a fourth to a third of American sociologists tend to "react to ideas with moral outrage rather than careful argumentation and exploration" https://t.co/6Ei0Tl1Ztq
RT @GUILLAZO: Para sorpresa de nadie en ningún lugar, evidencia actual demuestra que el 83% (OCHENTA Y TRES) de los sociólogos son o de izq…
@adleande @JoonasKiviranta Tuore lähde (2018): https://t.co/WDdY8RAVhO
RT @NoahCarl90: In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, '…
RT @NoahCarl90: In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, '…
RT @NoahCarl90: @AmirSariaslan This may be of interest: https://t.co/xyhAcQopeU
RT @NoahCarl90: In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, '…
@AmirSariaslan This may be of interest: https://t.co/xyhAcQopeU
RT @NoahCarl90: In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, '…
RT @NoahCarl90: In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, '…
RT @NoahCarl90: In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, '…
@NickWolfinger This may be of interest: https://t.co/xyhAcQopeU
@uglyluhan @jaegar00 Sociology as a field is ~2% conservative and ~85% left/liberal, with debates about whether it is "enough" to report the facts to students or if there is a "moral obligation" to be a left-wing activist as a sociologist. (Survey of 479
RT @NoahCarl90: In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, '…
RT @NoahCarl90: In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, '…
RT @NoahCarl90: In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, '…
RT @NoahCarl90: In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, '…
A majority of sociologists literally don't know what "sociology" means. Imagine if physicists smuggled moral or political ideology into their definition of "physics". It's *exactly* like that. That's not science.
RT @NoahCarl90: In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, '…
RT @NoahCarl90: In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, '…
…and here are some equally fascinating Horowitz et al findings on USA sociology and its relationships with 'sacred victims'. Striking finding here is that one third of USA sociologists don't see a 'moral mission' as part of sociology https://t.co/6az0pvLK9
RT @FriedrichHayek: "Sociologists" are not scientists, they are would-be social workers who manage to avoid doing any actual social work ..…
RT @NoahCarl90: In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, '…
"Sociologists" are not scientists, they are would-be social workers who manage to avoid doing any actual social work ...
RT @NoahCarl90: In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, '…
RT @NoahCarl90: In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, '…
RT @NoahCarl90: In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, '…
RT @NoahCarl90: In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, '…
I'm like 80% sure that the person posting about this very good thing believes that it is a very bad thing.
RT @NoahCarl90: In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, '…
RT @NoahCarl90: In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, '…
RT @NoahCarl90: In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, '…
RT @NoahCarl90: In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, '…
RT @NoahCarl90: In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, '…
RT @NoahCarl90: In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, '…
In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed ~479 American Sociology professors. 59% agreed with the statement, 'A central aim of sociology should be to analyze and transcend all forms of social oppression' https://t.co/fkOPji91wU
In a 2018 study, Mark Horowitz and colleagues surveyed 479 American Sociology professors. 83% identified as 'Liberal' or 'Radical', 13% identified as 'Moderate', and 4% identified as 'Conservative' or 'Libertarian' https://t.co/fkOPji91wU
RT @KirkegaardEmil: So, why so many sociologists among the usual petition signers? This survey throws some light on the matter. Most of th…
L'article original se trouve ici : https://t.co/6Ei0Tl1Ztq
This huge thread (from an article well worth reading) is now complete
What an in informative breakdown!
Finally taking the time to read 'Sociology’s Sacred Victims and the Politics of Knowledge: Moral Foundations Theory and Disciplinary Controversies' by Mark Horowitz, Anthony Haynor, Kenneth Kickham https://t.co/6Ei0Tl1Ztq
@JorgelinaM_ También sería interesante analizar por qué los sociólogos tienen un sesgo tan marcado hacia la izquierda y el estatismo. No solo en Argentina sino a nivel mundial https://t.co/C4uBl3l59D
@Kum0kun En retour de votre article, critiquez-vous le caractère anti-scientifique de la sociologie soumise à ses valeurs sacrées ? Cf. https://t.co/uwHhIBHHAO
@R_Sanders_SMH @coachblade @SwipeWright @HeatherEHeying @EricRWeinstein Yes and no. This is worth reading. https://t.co/lFO5xLkQ8D
@Kum0kun Sinon du côté des USA vous avez : https://t.co/InaJmfJ37G
@jprepo1 @HPluckrose @Citrauq @keikoinboston @LjRamones @SkepticReview89 @peterboghossian @HdxAcademy Indeed. We could only derive our conclusion that sociology was (partially) infected by this from having read sociology papers in the process, not by them
RT @ConceptualJames: In the wake of our grievance studies probe, we got some pushback about our claim that sociology is under the creeping…
RT @ConceptualJames: In the wake of our grievance studies probe, we got some pushback about our claim that sociology is under the creeping…
RT @ConceptualJames: In the wake of our grievance studies probe, we got some pushback about our claim that sociology is under the creeping…
RT @ConceptualJames: In the wake of our grievance studies probe, we got some pushback about our claim that sociology is under the creeping…
RT @ConceptualJames: In the wake of our grievance studies probe, we got some pushback about our claim that sociology is under the creeping…
RT @ConceptualJames: In the wake of our grievance studies probe, we got some pushback about our claim that sociology is under the creeping…
RT @ConceptualJames: In the wake of our grievance studies probe, we got some pushback about our claim that sociology is under the creeping…
RT @ConceptualJames: In the wake of our grievance studies probe, we got some pushback about our claim that sociology is under the creeping…
RT @ConceptualJames: In the wake of our grievance studies probe, we got some pushback about our claim that sociology is under the creeping…
RT @ConceptualJames: In the wake of our grievance studies probe, we got some pushback about our claim that sociology is under the creeping…
"The results, we suggest, can be understood by conceptualizing the field of sociology as an “emotive community.”" Never a true word.
RT @ConceptualJames: In the wake of our grievance studies probe, we got some pushback about our claim that sociology is under the creeping…
RT @ConceptualJames: In the wake of our grievance studies probe, we got some pushback about our claim that sociology is under the creeping…
In the wake of our grievance studies probe, we got some pushback about our claim that sociology is under the creeping influence of grievance studies because our probe didn't directly reveal this fact. I encourage reading this paper in full. https://t.co/lF
RT @ConceptualJames: A paper in The American Sociologist (peer-reviewed scholarly journal) identifies (many) sociologists as a part of an "…
Comunidade sociológica como "comunidade emocional" https://t.co/344coRLVP4
Lots of tables somewhat distract from powerful message re sociology and possible political bias https://t.co/diHYt26nah
RT @ConceptualJames: A paper in The American Sociologist (peer-reviewed scholarly journal) identifies (many) sociologists as a part of an "…
RT @ConceptualJames: A paper in The American Sociologist (peer-reviewed scholarly journal) identifies (many) sociologists as a part of an "…
RT @ConceptualJames: A paper in The American Sociologist (peer-reviewed scholarly journal) identifies (many) sociologists as a part of an "…
RT @ConceptualJames: A paper in The American Sociologist (peer-reviewed scholarly journal) identifies (many) sociologists as a part of an "…