i just submitted a peer review and I was very tempted to cite @MishaTeplitskiy on ’frame search’ and say, ‘my policy as reviewer is to only comment on empirics, framing is up to authors’ but I chickened out. Should I have done it? https://t.co/IUXKWCoNtR
Frame Search and Re-search: How Quantitative Sociological Articles Change During Peer Review, 5 years old https://t.co/g7xKSbyXaL
I’m curious specifically about Econ, but this one about sociology, by @MishaTeplitskiy, is the only one I know of… https://t.co/ZpRgGR9JAq
@joshua_a_becker Relevant paper on this by @MishaTeplitskiy: https://t.co/5LSoCVhGud
RT @MishaTeplitskiy: @Richvn @MNoel75 @EGU_ACP Hi Richard, agreed that we're sitll waiting for a good large-scale study, but these may be o…
@Richvn @MNoel75 @EGU_ACP Hi Richard, agreed that we're sitll waiting for a good large-scale study, but these may be of interest: - https://t.co/v2yrG8k9th - https://t.co/KoeQpvvnmB - https://t.co/nwSYCQTPxn
RT @uranus_2: 社会学の研究で査読中の改訂はデータ解析より理論的な方面の方が多い。Frame Search and Re-search: How Quantitative Sociological Articles Change During…https://t.c…
社会学の研究で査読中の改訂はデータ解析より理論的な方面の方が多い。Frame Search and Re-search: How Quantitative Sociological Articles Change During…https://t.co/GOiRT2uqBP
He's compared sociology conf papers and final studies, and found reviewers forced more changes to theory than data http://t.co/4ZPRHc99aR
RT @ISPP_JSC: how #quantitative #sociological articles change during #peerreview http://t.co/bGWOQLr8YR
how #quantitative #sociological articles change during #peerreview http://t.co/bGWOQLr8YR