RT @BMCBiology: ‘Any jackass can trash a manuscript’ - great MboC Editorialfrom 2011. But how to prevent ‘pit bull reviewing?’ https://t.co…
‘Any jackass can trash a manuscript’ - great MboC Editorialfrom 2011. But how to prevent ‘pit bull reviewing?’ https://t.co/bT84BRFTdQ https://t.co/Mw3f4KRNex
8 years on and still relevant: "Are we training pit bulls to review our manuscripts?" - Virginia Walbot. https://t.co/sNyWJs5N3V
Reminded me of "Are we training pit bulls to review our manuscripts?" https://t.co/ZxIC9zIQAC https://t.co/iNYb4TTGuX
Are we training pit bulls to review our manuscripts? https://t.co/BSjQ12tNOm
RT @bradylabs: Fantastic article with good points on reviewing, publishing and training... https://t.co/1ZHgxvzOn4
RT @lifesciences_GE: Are we training pit bulls to review #manuscripts? Interesting article on #research in #science and publishable units h…
Are we training pit bulls to review #manuscripts? Interesting article on #research in #science and publishable units https://t.co/tjioxVbzQx
Very interesting and worth a read https://t.co/7Cw3AICAWf
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
Thanks for suggesting this thoughtful paper on teaching graduate students https://t.co/iQxT2v5PK4
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @pcronald: How do we teach what constitutes a timely 'publishable unit' – not complete proof of a major concept but a defined step in t…
Retweeted 40 times before I noticed I spelled Ginny wrong. #FacePalm https://t.co/zqiwTzHhZy
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
H/t @surt_lab for rt on my feed. #peerreview #productive #criticism https://t.co/K4koV15zMr
RT @pcronald: How do we teach what constitutes a timely 'publishable unit' – not complete proof of a major concept but a defined step in t…
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @pcronald: How do we teach what constitutes a timely 'publishable unit' – not complete proof of a major concept but a defined step in t…
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @pcronald: How do we teach what constitutes a timely 'publishable unit' – not complete proof of a major concept but a defined step in t…
How do we teach what constitutes a timely 'publishable unit' – not complete proof of a major concept but a defined step in that direction? https://t.co/1vX3gYgliW
Probably disputable (like everything else related to publishing), but some very nice suggestions for teaching! https://t.co/hVpQPFRGC4
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @bradylabs: Fantastic article with good points on reviewing, publishing and training... https://t.co/1ZHgxvzOn4
RT @bradylabs: Fantastic article with good points on reviewing, publishing and training... https://t.co/1ZHgxvzOn4
Fantastic article with good points on reviewing, publishing and training... https://t.co/1ZHgxvzOn4
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @EdinaErds: Are we training pit bulls to review our manuscripts? https://t.co/Q2OOWyjEib
Are we training pit bulls to review our manuscripts? https://t.co/Q2OOWyjEib
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
https://t.co/OQuRWm0QCq @ajmiller4233 @MLinkPerez @megrua @plantsinspace @HopeJahren @realscientists @BerondaM Great paper on reviewing ms!
@kelly_mayrink a good resource for the class https://t.co/e0XvNygYPT
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
RT @jrossibarra: I’d missed this. “Are we training pit bulls to be our reviewers?” Nice points from Ginnie Walbot: https://t.co/Ilhth5emtb
I find it really hard not to be scathing in reviews. Reading this, mid-review, to try to counter this instinct: https://t.co/Taspy5YJs3
@nicgaston @m_onlein @astro_jje I prefer 2 treat such referees as Bogarts & equip students with the Riddikulus charm https://t.co/aXpIAwD5Db
@nicgaston @m_onlein @astro_jje but maybe the worst thing 4 colleagues is not showing students bad referee comments? https://t.co/aXpIAwD5Db
RT @Srgurr: Similar message. Are we training pit bulls to review our manuscripts? https://t.co/2lslBJoF2L #journalofbiology https://t.co/X…
RT @Srgurr: Similar message. Are we training pit bulls to review our manuscripts? https://t.co/2lslBJoF2L #journalofbiology https://t.co/X…
RT @Srgurr: Similar message. Are we training pit bulls to review our manuscripts? https://t.co/2lslBJoF2L #journalofbiology https://t.co/X…
RT @Srgurr: Similar message. Are we training pit bulls to review our manuscripts? https://t.co/2lslBJoF2L #journalofbiology https://t.co/X…
RT @Srgurr: Similar message. Are we training pit bulls to review our manuscripts? https://t.co/2lslBJoF2L #journalofbiology https://t.co/X…
Similar message. Are we training pit bulls to review our manuscripts? https://t.co/2lslBJoF2L #journalofbiology https://t.co/XWg1ih5jID
@CoSMDean Are we training pit bulls to review our manuscripts? http://t.co/JwK0yhSgRP
RT @Jack_Heinemann: @beachvetlbc @toqlip @FarmFairyCrafts @FrankNamet The practice may be endemic in our science culture. http://t.co/KSycO…
@beachvetlbc @toqlip @FarmFairyCrafts @FrankNamet The practice may be endemic in our science culture. http://t.co/KSycOx7NgH
@PeppeGanga hi peppe...your are the victim of a pitbull http://t.co/g2YXbRQxLm Are we training pit bulls to review our manuscripts?
To learn about good reviewing we need examples of the opposite. Interested @ivanoransky ? Training too. http://t.co/4gDGIMEVmZ
GR students starting to write articles; How to prevent vicious culture. Are we training pit bulls to review article: http://t.co/ncYAvkqDOI
Nice commentary on being a considerate reviewer: http://t.co/fo8KVNGqys
maybe we are indeed "training pit bull-like reviewers": #PPPR http://t.co/i27N2zRRJk
every #grad student and #academician should read: via @JenniferRedig pitbulls for reviewers article: http://t.co/i27N2zRRJk
@AboutGradSchool @blue_and_black1 @Norsebysw pitbulls for reviewers article: http://t.co/OSweyyqxQH
@AboutGradSchool @blue_and_black1 @Norsebysw pitbulls for reviewers article: http://t.co/OSweyyqxQH
"Are we training pit bulls to review our manuscripts" http://t.co/mpJ2c4uiAh
Check out this paper: http://t.co/1639PJsRDr (via @papersapp)
Walbot 'Are we training pit bulls to review our manuscripts?' - suggestions for training peer reviwers http://t.co/35ceCm0ltx
#PeerReview Are we training pit bulls to review our #manuscripts? http://t.co/vJwBQYRlPX
But that editorial manifests my pet hate: the abstract is not a summary but an introduction. http://t.co/UZ6daej52v It ends with a question!
I have certainly had some reviews that fit the relentlessly negative "pit-bull" profile described here http://t.co/UZ6daej52v
Excellent editorial from 2009: Are we training pit bulls to review our manuscripts? (Virginia Walbot) http://t.co/UZ6daej52v
Are you a 'pit-bull' reviewer? http://t.co/valnMitjnc
Are you a 'pit-bull' reviewer? http://t.co/valnMitjnc
from: "Are we training pit bulls to review our manuscripts?" http://t.co/W2cyRxZxub and "Domesticating the beast" http://t.co/kRiTAGt1n5
Are we training pit bulls to review our manuscripts? http://t.co/MHDhR8WZ3M
Joe Easterly mentioned article: http://t.co/RHgZaNCT training graduates to be pit bulls in review #thatcampwny
Are we training pit bulls to review our manuscripts? http://t.co/K9MY9NLH via @danmacclean
Check out this paper: http://t.co/N3J7lWXB (via @papersapp)
"Are we training pit bulls to review our manuscripts?" http://t.co/jfxHmjc7
"Are we training pit bulls to review our manuscripts?" - just found this 2009 publication: http://t.co/jf23noQT