類人猿のジェスチャーコミュニケーションとヒトのそれを区別するのは協力性。類人猿は〇〇するフリのような参照物の指示を意図した象徴的ジェスチャーや、他個体との共同目標の構築を達成できない。 Thirty years of great ape gestures https://t.co/Tih0NAGN1M
RT @Evol_of_Com: @SimonJGreenhill @allengrodrigo @AdamCSchembri @BiolTheory @kensycoop @lameira_adriano Of course. We compared gestural pro…
@SimonJGreenhill @allengrodrigo @AdamCSchembri @BiolTheory @kensycoop @lameira_adriano Of course. We compared gestural production across apes here: https://t.co/wZGn8yjQwm or https://t.co/OhvgE8wlJ2
Thirty years of great ape gestures https://t.co/DSghXDbmJK AnimCogn
“...it is also a mistake, to assimilate great ape gestures to human gestures by claiming that they are used referentially and declaratively in a human-like manner, as apes’ “pointing” gesture has many limitations and they do not gesture iconically” https:/
Paper reviewing the major consensus & disagreements in ape gesture work. Authors unsurprisingly conclude their own view is the the most sensible. 😋 https://t.co/swkqf1FQQZ
RT @AlexGRosati: "Great #ape #gestural #communication is interesting and important in its own right as a unique system of animal communicat…
Ever wanted to learn about great ape communication? In a handy paper, two researchers discuss their studies over the past 30 years indulging in all they have observed and learned about how unique great ape communication really is. #BI6192 https://t.co/tjq
30 years of great ape gestures https://t.co/JTH1EyJCHj
RT @BioTay: Esta imagen es un diccionario de gestos bonobo/chimpancé. Acaban de descubrir que pese a llevar separados más de 2 Ma sus gesto…
RT @BioTay: Esta imagen es un diccionario de gestos bonobo/chimpancé. Acaban de descubrir que pese a llevar separados más de 2 Ma sus gesto…
RT @BioTay: Esta imagen es un diccionario de gestos bonobo/chimpancé. Acaban de descubrir que pese a llevar separados más de 2 Ma sus gesto…
RT @BioTay: Esta imagen es un diccionario de gestos bonobo/chimpancé. Acaban de descubrir que pese a llevar separados más de 2 Ma sus gesto…
😮😮😮😮😮 https://t.co/ObACgMTjZm
Esta imagen es un diccionario de gestos bonobo/chimpancé. Acaban de descubrir que pese a llevar separados más de 2 Ma sus gestos siguen siendo muy parecidos (paper) https://t.co/WDLIHRnsi6 Son casi casi siempre imperativos (otro paper) https://t.co/x2PUDPK
@zannaclay @kirstyegraham @NakedPrimate But consider also this recent paper by Tomasello and Call on great ape gestures. They argue that they cannot assimilate to the species-typical displays of other mammals or to human gestures: they are a unique form of
RT @abenitezburraco: Interesting position paper by Tomasello and Call on great ape gestures. Take home message: they cannot assimilate to t…
Thirty years of great ape gestures. Michael Tomasello & Josep Call.#primatecommunication #apegestures #intentionalcommunication https://t.co/2uvUpGRn5J https://t.co/uwxP0W03Vo
RT @abenitezburraco: Interesting position paper by Tomasello and Call on great ape gestures. Take home message: they cannot assimilate to t…
İmportant : meaning they do not have addressee design ? https://t.co/Wgs6CdXCFV
RT @abenitezburraco: Interesting position paper by Tomasello and Call on great ape gestures. Take home message: they cannot assimilate to t…
RT @abenitezburraco: Interesting position paper by Tomasello and Call on great ape gestures. Take home message: they cannot assimilate to t…
RT @abenitezburraco: Interesting position paper by Tomasello and Call on great ape gestures. Take home message: they cannot assimilate to t…
Interesting position paper by Tomasello and Call on great ape gestures. Take home message: they cannot assimilate to the species-typical displays of other mammals or to human gestures: they are a unique form of primate communication https://t.co/SW0UMnZ5TZ
RT @DegenRolf: Although great apes can engage in gesturing, pointing and even sign language, these utterances are always imperatives, never…
RT @shona_d: Tomasello & Call's perspective on 30 years of work on ape gestures https://t.co/1Qye4ErB98 #comparativecognition
RT @GestureSociety: Looking back on 'Thirty years of great ape gestures.' https://t.co/BpeXFk9FMT
RT @GestureSociety: Looking back on 'Thirty years of great ape gestures.' https://t.co/BpeXFk9FMT
RT @GestureSociety: Looking back on 'Thirty years of great ape gestures.' https://t.co/BpeXFk9FMT
RT @GestureSociety: Looking back on 'Thirty years of great ape gestures.' https://t.co/BpeXFk9FMT
Looking back on 'Thirty years of great ape gestures.' https://t.co/BpeXFk9FMT
RT @DegenRolf: Although great apes can engage in gesturing, pointing and even sign language, these utterances are always imperatives, never…
RT @shona_d: Tomasello & Call's perspective on 30 years of work on ape gestures https://t.co/1Qye4ErB98 #comparativecognition
RT @SemplePrimate: Nice review of the 30 years of research on great ape gestural communication...https://t.co/ObuqWG6Va2 https://t.co/NTdpG…
RT @SemplePrimate: Nice review of the 30 years of research on great ape gestural communication...https://t.co/ObuqWG6Va2 https://t.co/NTdpG…
RT @SemplePrimate: Nice review of the 30 years of research on great ape gestural communication...https://t.co/ObuqWG6Va2 https://t.co/NTdpG…
RT @shona_d: Tomasello & Call's perspective on 30 years of work on ape gestures https://t.co/1Qye4ErB98 #comparativecognition
RT @SemplePrimate: Nice review of the 30 years of research on great ape gestural communication...https://t.co/ObuqWG6Va2 https://t.co/NTdpG…
RT @SemplePrimate: Nice review of the 30 years of research on great ape gestural communication...https://t.co/ObuqWG6Va2 https://t.co/NTdpG…
RT @AlexGRosati: "Great #ape #gestural #communication is interesting and important in its own right as a unique system of animal communicat…
RT @SemplePrimate: Nice review of the 30 years of research on great ape gestural communication...https://t.co/ObuqWG6Va2 https://t.co/NTdpG…
If there's a better way to start the day than learning all about ape communication then I don't want to know*: https://t.co/6jMKvKCLn1 *I also don't want to hear about more relevant or productive ones.
RT @DegenRolf: Although great apes can engage in gesturing, pointing and even sign language, these utterances are always imperatives, never…
RT @DegenRolf: Although great apes can engage in gesturing, pointing and even sign language, these utterances are always imperatives, never…
RT @SemplePrimate: Nice review of the 30 years of research on great ape gestural communication...https://t.co/ObuqWG6Va2 https://t.co/NTdpG…
RT @SemplePrimate: Nice review of the 30 years of research on great ape gestural communication...https://t.co/ObuqWG6Va2 https://t.co/NTdpG…
RT @shona_d: Tomasello & Call's perspective on 30 years of work on ape gestures https://t.co/1Qye4ErB98 #comparativecognition
RT @AlexGRosati: "Great #ape #gestural #communication is interesting and important in its own right as a unique system of animal communicat…
RT @AlexGRosati: "Great #ape #gestural #communication is interesting and important in its own right as a unique system of animal communicat…
RT @shona_d: Tomasello & Call's perspective on 30 years of work on ape gestures https://t.co/1Qye4ErB98 #comparativecognition
RT @AlexGRosati: "Great #ape #gestural #communication is interesting and important in its own right as a unique system of animal communicat…
RT @DegenRolf: Although great apes can engage in gesturing, pointing and even sign language, these utterances are always imperatives, never…
RT @k_shivers: This explains the appeal of Mike Cernovich https://t.co/fDQs8jaOdr
RT @DegenRolf: Although great apes can engage in gesturing, pointing and even sign language, these utterances are always imperatives, never…
RT @shona_d: Tomasello & Call's perspective on 30 years of work on ape gestures https://t.co/1Qye4ErB98 #comparativecognition
RT @ozyurek_a: oh excellent !!! @GestureSignLab (perfect for teaching :)) https://t.co/op6f0VlGnc
RT @DegenRolf: Although great apes can engage in gesturing, pointing and even sign language, these utterances are always imperatives, never…
RT @DegenRolf: Although great apes can engage in gesturing, pointing and even sign language, these utterances are always imperatives, never…
RT @shona_d: Tomasello & Call's perspective on 30 years of work on ape gestures https://t.co/1Qye4ErB98 #comparativecognition
RT @suzyjstyles: Interesting looking paper for next session of Ape's Guide to Human Language @dear_apes https://t.co/pNvorfysJJ
Interesting looking paper for next session of Ape's Guide to Human Language @dear_apes https://t.co/pNvorfysJJ
"Great #ape #gestural #communication is interesting and important in its own right as a unique system of animal communication. But it is also interesting and important because it very likely represents the evolutionary starting point for human linguistic c
RT @shona_d: Tomasello & Call's perspective on 30 years of work on ape gestures https://t.co/1Qye4ErB98 #comparativecognition
RT @shona_d: Tomasello & Call's perspective on 30 years of work on ape gestures https://t.co/1Qye4ErB98 #comparativecognition
RT @DegenRolf: Although great apes can engage in gesturing, pointing and even sign language, these utterances are always imperatives, never…
RT @shona_d: Tomasello & Call's perspective on 30 years of work on ape gestures https://t.co/1Qye4ErB98 #comparativecognition
RT @shona_d: Tomasello & Call's perspective on 30 years of work on ape gestures https://t.co/1Qye4ErB98 #comparativecognition
RT @SemplePrimate: Nice review of the 30 years of research on great ape gestural communication...https://t.co/ObuqWG6Va2 https://t.co/NTdpG…
RT @ozyurek_a: oh excellent !!! @GestureSignLab (perfect for teaching :)) https://t.co/op6f0VlGnc
RT @shona_d: Tomasello & Call's perspective on 30 years of work on ape gestures https://t.co/1Qye4ErB98 #comparativecognition
RT @DegenRolf: Although great apes can engage in gesturing, pointing and even sign language, these utterances are always imperatives, never…
RT @shona_d: Tomasello & Call's perspective on 30 years of work on ape gestures https://t.co/1Qye4ErB98 #comparativecognition
RT @shona_d: Tomasello & Call's perspective on 30 years of work on ape gestures https://t.co/1Qye4ErB98 #comparativecognition
RT @DegenRolf: Although great apes can engage in gesturing, pointing and even sign language, these utterances are always imperatives, never…
RT @shona_d: Tomasello & Call's perspective on 30 years of work on ape gestures https://t.co/1Qye4ErB98 #comparativecognition
RT @shona_d: Tomasello & Call's perspective on 30 years of work on ape gestures https://t.co/1Qye4ErB98 #comparativecognition
Our very own Josep Call, a fantastic colleague and brilliant scientist. https://t.co/YbVcH83nkK
RT @shona_d: Tomasello & Call's perspective on 30 years of work on ape gestures https://t.co/1Qye4ErB98 #comparativecognition
RT @shona_d: Tomasello & Call's perspective on 30 years of work on ape gestures https://t.co/1Qye4ErB98 #comparativecognition
RT @ozyurek_a: oh excellent !!! @GestureSignLab (perfect for teaching :)) https://t.co/op6f0VlGnc
RT @DegenRolf: Although great apes can engage in gesturing, pointing and even sign language, these utterances are always imperatives, never…
RT @shona_d: Tomasello & Call's perspective on 30 years of work on ape gestures https://t.co/1Qye4ErB98 #comparativecognition
oh excellent !!! @GestureSignLab (perfect for teaching :)) https://t.co/op6f0VlGnc
RT @SemplePrimate: Nice review of the 30 years of research on great ape gestural communication...https://t.co/ObuqWG6Va2 https://t.co/NTdpG…
RT @SemplePrimate: Nice review of the 30 years of research on great ape gestural communication...https://t.co/ObuqWG6Va2 https://t.co/NTdpG…
RT @SemplePrimate: Nice review of the 30 years of research on great ape gestural communication...https://t.co/ObuqWG6Va2 https://t.co/NTdpG…
RT @SemplePrimate: Nice review of the 30 years of research on great ape gestural communication...https://t.co/ObuqWG6Va2 https://t.co/NTdpG…
RT @DegenRolf: Although great apes can engage in gesturing, pointing and even sign language, these utterances are always imperatives, never…
RT @SemplePrimate: Nice review of the 30 years of research on great ape gestural communication...https://t.co/ObuqWG6Va2 https://t.co/NTdpG…
Nice review of the 30 years of research on great ape gestural communication...https://t.co/ObuqWG6Va2 https://t.co/NTdpG2A08F
RT @shona_d: Tomasello & Call's perspective on 30 years of work on ape gestures https://t.co/1Qye4ErB98 #comparativecognition
Tomasello & Call's perspective on 30 years of work on ape gestures https://t.co/1Qye4ErB98 #comparativecognition
RT @DegenRolf: Although great apes can engage in gesturing, pointing and even sign language, these utterances are always imperatives, never…
RT @DegenRolf: Although great apes can engage in gesturing, pointing and even sign language, these utterances are always imperatives, never…
RT @DegenRolf: Although great apes can engage in gesturing, pointing and even sign language, these utterances are always imperatives, never…
RT @DegenRolf: Although great apes can engage in gesturing, pointing and even sign language, these utterances are always imperatives, never…
There's another interpretation, namely that apes' points essentially have both imperative and declarative aspects. E.g. they point to an object (declarative) in order to get it (imperative). That points are never purely declarative does not mean they are p
RT @DegenRolf: Although great apes can engage in gesturing, pointing and even sign language, these utterances are always imperatives, never…
Although great apes can engage in gesturing, pointing and even sign language, these utterances are always imperatives, never aimed at informing others of things. https://t.co/zLZQGoqIYY https://t.co/vCMpC2veuw
Thirty years of great ape gestures, by Michael Tomasello and Josep Call https://t.co/mRnKWQSPOo "We and our colleagues have been doing studies of great ape gestural communication for more than 30 years. Here we attempt to spell out what we have learned.