What’s in a Name: Exposing Gender Bias in Student Ratings of Teaching

@ProfVallet Un "classique" que vous avez peut-être lu : https://t.co/ePmRQVrY9z Celui-ci plus recemment : https://t.co/BFlVuJJ8nt Grand sujet de discussion (et de 🤦‍♂️) depuis longtemps de mon côté (hein @MariLeBechec).

@HungerfordHil Here are two RCTs looking at gender bias. https://t.co/azsCsWmb5e https://t.co/hD40Q0pyNu

@ChandlerLab @pshefty and this one: https://t.co/Hb7YZXPgTB

RT @bethallisonbarr: I can't help be reminded of all the studies showing how female academics & high-achieving women face greater criticism…

RT @bethallisonbarr: I can't help be reminded of all the studies showing how female academics & high-achieving women face greater criticism…

RT @bethallisonbarr: I can't help be reminded of all the studies showing how female academics & high-achieving women face greater criticism…

I can't help be reminded of all the studies showing how female academics & high-achieving women face greater criticisms than men re emotion: https://t.co/sGCL6GhgDt https://t.co/RviekAOjEQ https://t.co/QKMXzlofgM Y'all, it is just patriarchy. I think I

@Unic0rnp0w3r An interesting thread here: https://t.co/q8632p8Jvy

@SDMumford • Lillian MacNell, Adam Driscoll, Andrea N. Hunt, "What's in a Name: Exposing Gender Bias in Student Ratings of Teaching", Innovative Higher Education 40, no. 4 (2015): 291-303, https://t.co/TQFdphEsas 12/+

@bethfelkerjones Do you know the MacNeill, Driscoll(!), Hunt paper on this? Randomly assigning gendered names for an online course. The design is beautiful, the results are devastating. https://t.co/FYnPR8O5hT

And also: https://t.co/Z2JpaEHXuQ

RT @ErikaDNolte: @lmacthompson1 I truly don’t know why we even do student evals anymore. https://t.co/EyjyHh1rqR

@lmacthompson1 I truly don’t know why we even do student evals anymore. https://t.co/EyjyHh1rqR

What’s in a Name: Exposing Gender Bias in Student Ratings of Teaching https://t.co/NNasOeBZ3I No sé si estoy sorprendida, pero siempre triste.

Links from the slide: https://t.co/R0GNMjSppd

@TasanGroupMIT Unless the instructor is female, then it probably will have the reverse impact. https://t.co/BoyeZiIlAc

RT @tS0u: Ένα εξαιρετικό paper στο θέμα είναι αυτό που δείχνει gender bias και των ΜΑΘΗΤΩΝ απέναντι σε γυναίκες ακαδημαϊκούς. Σε σχετικό π…

RT @tS0u: Ένα εξαιρετικό paper στο θέμα είναι αυτό που δείχνει gender bias και των ΜΑΘΗΤΩΝ απέναντι σε γυναίκες ακαδημαϊκούς. Σε σχετικό π…

Ένα εξαιρετικό paper στο θέμα είναι αυτό που δείχνει gender bias και των ΜΑΘΗΤΩΝ απέναντι σε γυναίκες ακαδημαϊκούς. Σε σχετικό πείραμα φοιτητές δίνουν μεγαλύτερη βαθμολογία όταν υποθέτουν ότι ο καθηγητής είναι άνδρας έναντι της υπόθεσης ότι είναι γυναίκα.

@lacosmonaut4 Me vino a la cabeza porque sé de casos que en las encuestas bajan puntuaciones a profesoras por el hecho de ser mujeres, tal cual. ¿En qué aspectos? En los que se refieren al conocimiento del profesor, etc. Ya conocía el fenómeno, pero vaya,

RT @matbury: @timbocop If you need some evidence to point out the failings of student surveys about course quality, here's a few: https://t…

@timbocop If you need some evidence to point out the failings of student surveys about course quality, here's a few: https://t.co/BG3ral7bjG & https://t.co/3oJ9zEdmlY & https://t.co/vQLzw41yus & they're unfair to female teaching staff: https://

RT @SugimuraLab: @dritoshi 昨日教えてくださった学生の講義評価と成績が相関しないという調査結果の原因の一つかもしれません。 “ 教員の真の性別を知り得ない設定のオンライン講義で，教員が女性であると伝えられた学生は男性であると伝えられた学生よりも講義を低…

@dritoshi 昨日教えてくださった学生の講義評価と成績が相関しないという調査結果の原因の一つかもしれません。 “ 教員の真の性別を知り得ない設定のオンライン講義で，教員が女性であると伝えられた学生は男性であると伝えられた学生よりも講義を低く評価したという調査結果” https://t.co/yAZTGpHKbU

@GoWokeGoBroke4 @UNCpublichealth Ahem: https://t.co/ZF2L0ss0k4

RT @Christy_Avery: As course evaluation season rolls around, I always alert students to biases in teaching evals. In this example of gender…

RT @Christy_Avery: As course evaluation season rolls around, I always alert students to biases in teaching evals. In this example of gender…

As course evaluation season rolls around, I always alert students to biases in teaching evals. In this example of gender bias, note the higher mean ratings when the actual female is perceived male (and vice versa). #epitwitter #AcademicTwitter https://t.c

scores are affected by being identified as female, from 2015: https://t.co/gPxczYHnL4

RT @DrMeaganTyler: There is overwhelming evidence (see: https://t.co/wY7UCodDoO, for a start) that standard teaching evaluations disadvanta…

There is overwhelming evidence (see: https://t.co/wY7UCodDoO, for a start) that standard teaching evaluations disadvantage women in #highered and, particularly, minority women. In some studies, the penalty is found to be up to 0.8 on a five-point-scale. h

3. We know gender bias plays a role in qualitative evaluations of *all kinds*. This includes teaching evaluations, as documented in this article: https://t.co/zNfbKCGirD

@jenniferdoleac @bartonwillage @erinhengel @ShellyJLundberg Ah yes indeed! This: https://t.co/QlQ5CPOACO

https://t.co/VK2P4KhcPD

@SimonBillouet @CecileDuflot @thomascutuil Une étude 2014, avec ce genre de conclusions https://t.co/QbNQJHOAcR mais on trouve beaucoup de littérature pour les contester. (Par exemple, en 2016, Breda/Hillion.) Ne sachant pas analyser les différentes méthod

@HPS_Vanessa this pretty much happened, at least on the guy thing! https://t.co/waDhrpGR9j

https://t.co/g4D2WNhX66

@PlamenAkaliyski @Prof_FSultana @AcademicChatter If you don't want to read the whole article, here's the punchline: https://t.co/M4wDsVcVvb Don't miss: the 0.8 point drop for the female-percieved instructor on "Promptness", even though this was a control

@PlamenAkaliyski @Prof_FSultana @AcademicChatter There are a TON of peer-reviewed scientific papers on this, if you do a quick search. Here's a favorite of mine: https://t.co/YK6TbeaW3q

@RobertoCastillo @ceciliabettoni Hay varios estudios sobre el tema; por ejemplo: 1) https://t.co/ydnFllTIRv, 2) https://t.co/qlgsJ4gGbl y 3) https://t.co/yQ02nOwocB

RT @yy_yevdokimov: @AlexDalw @veritas_z студентов попросили оценить учителей М. и Ж.Учащиеся ни разу не видели учивших их людей. Когда одна…

мне нравится как этот чувак спокойно объясняет, приводя аргументы и доказательства и не давая сбить себя с мысли, пока некто с юзернеймом адольф гитлер (??????) гавкает

RT @yy_yevdokimov: @AlexDalw @veritas_z студентов попросили оценить учителей М. и Ж.Учащиеся ни разу не видели учивших их людей. Когда одна…

RT @yy_yevdokimov: @AlexDalw @veritas_z студентов попросили оценить учителей М. и Ж.Учащиеся ни разу не видели учивших их людей. Когда одна…

RT @yy_yevdokimov: @AlexDalw @veritas_z студентов попросили оценить учителей М. и Ж.Учащиеся ни разу не видели учивших их людей. Когда одна…

RT @yy_yevdokimov: @AlexDalw @veritas_z студентов попросили оценить учителей М. и Ж.Учащиеся ни разу не видели учивших их людей. Когда одна…

RT @yy_yevdokimov: @AlexDalw @veritas_z студентов попросили оценить учителей М. и Ж.Учащиеся ни разу не видели учивших их людей. Когда одна…

@AlexDalw @veritas_z студентов попросили оценить учителей М. и Ж.Учащиеся ни разу не видели учивших их людей. Когда одна группа дала более высокую оценку мужчине,преподаватели поменялись именами, и следующая группа дала более высокую оценку предполагаемому

@gporlezza https://t.co/N4yL7YLUPP

@AppleMath2 @Persuasion_Elli https://t.co/Om0ovsRjKe https://t.co/cdOWCYkZdA

@cbgoodman Student gender bias in teaching evaluations has been established, especially online. For examples see: https://t.co/RlIjFdAo3R https://t.co/tDdQ9GExoT https://t.co/39BrcmhxYm

@gbaucom https://t.co/X5kP8Zg5jK 2017 https://t.co/JqZOZPGdca 2015 Just a few, there are tons of studies about this still.....

@Metal_Crow @DrRachaelF @dave13traffic @NPR https://t.co/DRTMIRhxl6

RT @JonathanTummons: @cristinacost @DrKimberlyJamie Or that student evaluations of teaching are posited as objective measures to be used as…

@cristinacost @DrKimberlyJamie Or that student evaluations of teaching are posited as objective measures to be used as evidence for promotion when we can argue that they are inherently biased: https://t.co/E1gDE7QdvK

yikes https://t.co/CrAMAdKGEz

@ChloeEast2 I'll stop after this one, but this is a cool study where in an online course, they lied about the professor's gender to see how that influenced the student evals: https://t.co/Ev3aHTAGED

RT @christineliuart: Bias is not something you can just "pull your bootstraps up" to overcome. In a study of an online class where the perc…

RT @christineliuart: Bias is not something you can just "pull your bootstraps up" to overcome. In a study of an online class where the perc…

RT @christineliuart: Bias is not something you can just "pull your bootstraps up" to overcome. In a study of an online class where the perc…

Bias is not something you can just "pull your bootstraps up" to overcome. In a study of an online class where the perceived gender of the teacher was manipulated, students ranked the teacher lower if they thought the teacher was female. https://t.co/4rja6

@crgfrench @Val_Mueller_ASU I'm afraid the basic findings are incredibly robust and have been replicated many times. More studies further down in the thread, and many more if you want to search. E.g. https://t.co/wgvzEzuZf9 uses same instructors teaching s

RT @thstockinger: @daniel_r_james @BritLitGirl @TheTattooedProf Or this one: https://t.co/rdRAUytSOs

RT @thstockinger: @daniel_r_james @BritLitGirl @TheTattooedProf Or this one: https://t.co/rdRAUytSOs

RT @thstockinger: @daniel_r_james @BritLitGirl @TheTattooedProf Or this one: https://t.co/rdRAUytSOs

RT @thstockinger: @daniel_r_james @BritLitGirl @TheTattooedProf Or this one: https://t.co/rdRAUytSOs

RT @thstockinger: @daniel_r_james @BritLitGirl @TheTattooedProf Or this one: https://t.co/rdRAUytSOs

RT @thstockinger: @daniel_r_james @BritLitGirl @TheTattooedProf Or this one: https://t.co/rdRAUytSOs

RT @thstockinger: @daniel_r_james @BritLitGirl @TheTattooedProf Or this one: https://t.co/rdRAUytSOs

RT @thstockinger: @daniel_r_james @BritLitGirl @TheTattooedProf Or this one: https://t.co/rdRAUytSOs

@Sydonahi Does this work for you? https://t.co/rPgqPOAjBt

Hello peeps! This reference is behind a paywall for me, can anyone access it and send me the pdf please :) ? https://t.co/FzdSLI31n4

RT @6MileFlyGuy: Also given the biases of evaluations based on gender (https://t.co/6JWuIdiyqw) it is amazing how much weight they carrying…

Also given the biases of evaluations based on gender (https://t.co/6JWuIdiyqw) it is amazing how much weight they carrying in faculty evaluations.

@daliejimenez I think it was this one: https://t.co/Zg9bSlXP9n

@caseyduehackney https://t.co/et2irltWEu

RT @profmusgrave: Students in an online course give higher ratings to instructors with male names https://t.co/xl4S4DYBWl), https://t.co/Pt…

RT @palomaraggo: :( https://t.co/O1JCOGAKaT

:(

RT @profmusgrave: Students in an online course give higher ratings to instructors with male names https://t.co/xl4S4DYBWl), https://t.co/Pt…

Really thought provoking and definitive proof (in case anyone still has doubt).

RT @Mika_Sandstrom: @jmkorhonen Unohtamatta "In our experiment, assistant instructors in an online class each operated under two different…

RT @Mika_Sandstrom: @jmkorhonen Unohtamatta "In our experiment, assistant instructors in an online class each operated under two different…

@jmkorhonen Unohtamatta "In our experiment, assistant instructors in an online class each operated under two different gender identities. Students rated the male identity significantly higher than the female identity..." https://t.co/v8Udlqp6jA

@JonPuritz https://t.co/ZhhiavKeU4),

RT @bendybiologist: MacNell et al 2015 exposes gender bias in the way that students rate the quality of their professors teaching ability.…

https://t.co/W2VqNhKh6d https://t.co/i1qAOD3LHK https://t.co/j6nnvxMjJ8 https://t.co/F2XEcZ8OiJ https://t.co/Q9bMSmhPAQ

MacNell et al 2015 exposes gender bias in the way that students rate the quality of their professors teaching ability. How can we learn to avoid this? #SexinScience #SexDiffsUMich https://t.co/39nePwhifK

Association of an individual's (student's) implicit bias towards gender role and behavior in rating of an instructor in academia. We believe that we are thinking rationally, but how many times implicit bias override the rational brain. #SexinScience. https

(2/4) Male teaching assistants get better reviews. How was this proved? An online female TA taught one section using her real name and another using a male-typical name. Same TA, better reviews with a boy name https://t.co/2lXseLbDZf

RT @EmmaKEdDev: To the men (it's always the men) "challenging" the gender bias in student evaluations: here's a study that showed students…

RT @EmmaKEdDev: To the men (it's always the men) "challenging" the gender bias in student evaluations: here's a study that showed students…

Did you know that gender bias is pervasive in student evaluations, even when the teaching is done online? https://t.co/lmezT2mL7y

RT @EmmaKEdDev: To the men (it's always the men) "challenging" the gender bias in student evaluations: here's a study that showed students…

RT @EmmaKEdDev: To the men (it's always the men) "challenging" the gender bias in student evaluations: here's a study that showed students…

RT @EmmaKEdDev: To the men (it's always the men) "challenging" the gender bias in student evaluations: here's a study that showed students…

RT @EmmaKEdDev: To the men (it's always the men) "challenging" the gender bias in student evaluations: here's a study that showed students…

RT @EmmaKEdDev: To the men (it's always the men) "challenging" the gender bias in student evaluations: here's a study that showed students…

RT @EmmaKEdDev: To the men (it's always the men) "challenging" the gender bias in student evaluations: here's a study that showed students…

RT @EmmaKEdDev: To the men (it's always the men) "challenging" the gender bias in student evaluations: here's a study that showed students…