@robdykedotcom Oops! Just noticed I posted the same link twice 🤦♂️ Here's @NICEComms itself, in response to the York paper: https://t.co/VWuBRHCb12 Other views, from 2007: https://t.co/Qc1ujf3uy6 2014: https://t.co/EsFROJ3M3U and @NHSEngland, just
Second, NICE does not apply equity weights to the QALYs forgone by NHS patients who bear the opportunity cost of its decisions. This fundamental inequity has been recognized for years (e.g. this paper from 2014) but has not yet been addressed by NICE. [3]
Thanks Paul. I agree - NICE needs to be careful with modifiers. They must be accounted for in the opportunity cost, which means some new technologies will be *less* cost-effective than before. Logically, the weighted average threshold across all appraisals
I don't like these 'Modifiers' (among other things). #NICE seems to ignore that every decision to INCLUDE a new treatment into the system has the potential to EXCLUDE other, existing treatments. See this very clever paper by @mikepaulden et al (from 2014):
@DrChrisGibbons @catherine_max @jimmcmanusph @felly500 @nedwards_1 @benatipsosmori @EditorJRSM @albertpweale @kchalkidou @Kat_Kieslich Prof @McCabeC_IHE & @mikepaulden were not very complimentary abt @NICEcomms social values when they were first adopte
@werner_brouwer @PECjournal @ArthurAttema A comment & a question. 1. I agree w/ @mikepaulden & @McCabeC_IHE (1st pic, from https://t.co/C22anE1Tqw) that the so-called "social decision making perspective" is best described as maximizing present *va
Inconsistencies in @NICEcomms ’s Considratn of Social Values https://t.co/ZRBwR6uO2Z https://t.co/Y5AtOM6UoN via @mikepaulden & @MccabeCJM
RT @mikepaulden: Considering additional social values only if a technology is not cost-effective results in inconsistencies http://t.co/94r…
Considering additional social values only if a technology is not cost-effective results in inconsistencies http://t.co/94rVl0pPPe #CADTHsymp
Considering additional social values only if a technology is not cost-effective results in inconsistencies http://t.co/94rVl0pPPe #CADTHsymp
Considering additional social values only if a technology is not cost-effective results in inconsistencies http://t.co/94rVl0pPPe #CADTHsymp
Considering additional social values only if a technology is not cost-effective results in inconsistencies http://t.co/94rVl0pPPe #CADTHsymp
Some Inconsistencies in NICE’s Consideration of Social Values http://t.co/X0aC016rZr
Some Inconsistencies in @NICEcomms ’s Consideration of Social Values http://t.co/1m2bDwxnen via @MccabeCJM
Inconsistencies in NICE’s Consideration of Social Values (@MccabeCJM @mikepaulden et al) http://t.co/eyBtL1Q4nf #freetoaccess
Inconsistencies in NICE’s Consideration of Social Values (@MccabeCJM @mikepaulden et al) http://t.co/eyBtL1Q4nf #freetoaccess
Inconsistencies in NICE’s Consideration of Social Values http://t.co/H03QzG7XEX via @MccabeCJM @Valerie_VazMP
“@ruairidhm: Do NICE’s new appraisal methods pile "inconsistency upon inconsistency"? @MccabeCJM @mikepaulden http://t.co/UjeEgeOZtc”yes!
Interesting reading re VBA proposals.Some Inconsistencies in NICE’s Consideration of Social Values http://t.co/jmSSb4Jp5Z #springerlink
“@ruairidhm: Do NICE’s new appraisal methods pile "inconsistency upon inconsistency"? @MccabeCJM @mikepaulden http://t.co/UjeEgeOZtc”yes!
“@ruairidhm: Do NICE’s new appraisal methods pile "inconsistency upon inconsistency"? @MccabeCJM @mikepaulden http://t.co/UjeEgeOZtc”yes!
“@ruairidhm: Do NICE’s new appraisal methods pile "inconsistency upon inconsistency"? @MccabeCJM @mikepaulden http://t.co/UjeEgeOZtc”yes!
“@ruairidhm: Do NICE’s new appraisal methods pile "inconsistency upon inconsistency"? @MccabeCJM @mikepaulden http://t.co/UjeEgeOZtc”yes!
Do NICE’s new appraisal methods pile "inconsistency upon inconsistency"? @MccabeCJM @mikepaulden http://t.co/Uo39lK7ggi
Do NICE’s new appraisal methods pile "inconsistency upon inconsistency"? @MccabeCJM @mikepaulden http://t.co/Uo39lK7ggi
Do NICE’s new appraisal methods pile "inconsistency upon inconsistency"? @MccabeCJM @mikepaulden http://t.co/Uo39lK7ggi
Inconsistencies in NICE’s Consideration of Social Values (@MccabeCJM @mikepaulden et al) http://t.co/eyBtL1Q4nf #freetoaccess
Some Inconsistencies in NICE’s Consideration of Social Values http://t.co/1HVGxFWUly
Inconsistencies in NICE’s Consideration of Social Values (@MccabeCJM @mikepaulden et al) http://t.co/eyBtL1Q4nf #freetoaccess
Inconsistencies in NICE’s Consideration of Social Values (@MccabeCJM @mikepaulden et al) http://t.co/eyBtL1Q4nf #freetoaccess
Inconsistencies in NICE’s Consideration of Social Values (@MccabeCJM @mikepaulden et al) http://t.co/eyBtL1Q4nf #freetoaccess
“@mikepaulden: Some Inconsistencies in NICE’s Consideration of Social Values http://t.co/suozZz3hhe”
Some Inconsistencies in NICE’s Consideration of Social Values http://t.co/1HVGxFWUly
I'm reading Some Inconsistencies in NICE’s Consideration of Social Values http://t.co/hU33QeEaz8
Some Inconsistencies in NICE’s Consideration of Social Values http://t.co/1HVGxFWUly
#HealthEconJA Some Inconsistencies in NICE’s Consideration of Social Values http://t.co/5nsiDSqPfD
Some Inconsistencies in NICE’s Consideration of Social Values http://t.co/1HVGxFWUly
@NICEcomms proposed changes to HTA methods are flawed and poorly justified. (nice paper by @MccabeCJM et al.) http://t.co/eyBtL1Q4nf #HEOR
@NICEcomms proposed changes to HTA methods are flawed and poorly justified. (nice paper by @MccabeCJM et al.) http://t.co/eyBtL1Q4nf #HEOR
@NICEcomms proposed changes to HTA methods are flawed and poorly justified. (nice paper by @MccabeCJM et al.) http://t.co/eyBtL1Q4nf #HEOR