Far left legalists left communist Russia and learned English. #HailMary "If Abortion, then Infanticide David B Hershenov, Rose J Hershenov "Our contention is that all of the major arguments for abortion are also arguments for permitting infanticide." h
RT @strictlyRhythm_: @feminemi1y If you're curious why so many pro-abortion academics defend infanticide, read this paper that shows how al…
@IvesParrhesia @bryan_caplan https://t.co/Lsk7ykS50I both of the links in this tweet
@IvesParrhesia Using consciousness as your standard leads to counterintuitive results. The best papers on the issue: For fantastic objections to theories of personhood that exclude pro-life views https://t.co/zsXCZ0uKSg For a concrete reason for Hershen
@AlchemistNon Hershenov’s infanticide reductio: https://t.co/xeEKGjQjNu
@FeministPhilos Human beings have a rational nature which gives them a right to life even if they don't currently have advanced mental abilities. https://t.co/oYA68JZWa5 https://t.co/SSwll6sS6X But on the first point, if you think the lives of pigs and
@New_Catallaxy @Cas_And_Ra I definitely need to re-read Oderberg's essay. I find D. B. Hershenov's "If Abortion, then Infanticide" to be a pretty good demonstration of what we've been talking about in the thread. https://t.co/h9xfAfCsBd
@SmnkBfrUThnk @TheBasedTrinity @nbrink77 @sahbdeane @DK_Able It's from a popular essay by a philosopher. I re-worded it a little for my purposes. Here's the essay: https://t.co/h9xfAfD0qL
RT @jlandreu2014: Excelente hilo. Además, si se acepta el aborto, ¿por qué no el infanticidio antes de que la maduración cerebral haga surg…
Excelente hilo. Además, si se acepta el aborto, ¿por qué no el infanticidio antes de que la maduración cerebral haga surgir la autoconsciencia? La vida hay que protegerla sin plazos arbitrarios. https://t.co/BbV5vZ48AO
@JNPDC @akfeministfrog @to_discussion But it does. https://t.co/DP3sorXltj Counter-assertions aren't counter-arguments.
@akfeministfrog @JNPDC @to_discussion Generally speaking it is. D.B. Hershenov has proven this beyond reasonable doubt. https://t.co/DP3sorXltj
@TheGalacticRam If you're curious why so many pro-abortion academics defend infanticide, read this paper. All major defenses of abortion also justify infanticide of born infants. https://t.co/h9xfAfkRcD
@PurplePunkN @froggybsb03 @reaINathanD @Shamar_Ezer @DSiPaint @Janemarch888 @to_discussion @Maccabeus24 @latte_mama2 @Vjinxvalentine Yes it is. You just don't know your arguments. https://t.co/h9xfAfkRcD
@lezzlemynezzle @Wylene13 @cg_geometry @AGHamilton29 Lol so you can argue that going after IVF clinics is the logical conclusion of the pro-life position but i can't argue that infanticide is the logical consequence of the pro-abortion position? ;) Educat
@amye783 @IvanneD1 @Vixen95Trish @RadiantUchiha @Shamar_Ezer @laugh70797534 Personhood views on the pro-abortion side almost always entail the logical permissibility of infanticide of born infants. https://t.co/h9xfAfkRcD
@DibblerPies I think there is a good chance that all arguments for abortion lead to the absurdity that infanticide is permissible. https://t.co/zsXCZ0uKSg There's also Hendricks' argument (which is explained by the theory of moral value Hershenov lays out
@LakeRhino @madefrommeat @secularprolife All major defenses of abortion also justify infanticide of born "non-person" infants: https://t.co/h9xfAfkRcD This is precisely why leading pro-abortion bioethicists philosophers defend infanticide as a logical con
@CravensLilith @EmmaJClemmons @washingtonpost Your argument entails infanticide of born infants, which is why bioethicists and philosophers who appeal to sentience, etc. to defend abortion also defend infanticide. https://t.co/h9xfAfkRcD
@afrofemrage @snickerdeedoo @feminemi1y It does. You just don't know it because you don't know the arguments you use lol. https://t.co/0xVNIPQhF5
@BingoMontoya @Shamar_Ezer @pixelprotectors @BumpstockBarbie @RamboGardenGirl @KristanHawkins But it literally is denying personhood to an entire class of human beings. Defining personhood? Your own leading pro-abortion bioethicists & philosophers can'
@cathworkingmom @DGersh94 @MooreCritFaced @Shamar_Ezer @to_discussion @maryfiorito @cybermom1999 @shamnis9182 @She_Brings_Joy All major defenses of abortion also justify infanticide of born infants. https://t.co/h9xfAfkRcD
@feminemi1y If you're curious why so many pro-abortion academics defend infanticide, read this paper that shows how all major defenses of abortion also justify infanticide of born infants. https://t.co/h9xfAfkRcD
@SoOvaryActing @nativespecies @KeepToTheLight @mybiznoturs84 @Shamar_Ezer @to_discussion @again_jenn @latte_mama2 @Vlynx5 @fuzzymittens All major defenses of abortion also justify infanticide. Why do you think many of your leading pro-abortion bioethicists
@GentlemenBrian @__OlllO__ @gregg_re @greg_price11 Sure. Read David Hershenov's paper "If abortion, then infanticide" too, if you can. https://t.co/ipXLtpTM1D
@__OlllO__ @gregg_re @greg_price11 All major defenses of abortion also justify infanticide. Any logically consistent person will see this. https://t.co/h9xfAfkRcD
@aishpilled Don't forget this nightmare of a paper for pro choice philosophy: https://t.co/hOTM6C7VI2
@subastraa @Poetree_writer @She_Brings_Joy @btsy7 In general, all major defenses of abortion also justify infanticide of born infants. https://t.co/h9xfAfkRcD
@OwlFoxVT @ErichKays @cathworkingmom @secularprolife The point is this: as demonstrated by D. B. Hershenov in his paper, all major defenses of abortion also justify infanticide and leading pro-abortion philosophers know that. That's a logical consequence w
@ErichKays @OwlFoxVT @cathworkingmom @secularprolife All major defenses of abortion also justify infanticide. Any logically consistent person will see this. https://t.co/h9xfAfkRcD
@asteriaofnight @RonCole80482262 And, as demonstrated by D. B. Hershenov in his paper, all major defenses of abortion also justify infanticide. That's a logical consequence whether pro-aborts know it or not. https://t.co/h9xfAfkRcD
@shifter_cat @Anarcho_SRC @RobDye1960 @espiers And anyway, as demonstrated by D. B. Hershenov in his paper, all major defenses of abortion also justify infanticide. That's a logical consequence whether pro-aborts know it or not. https://t.co/h9xfAfkRcD
@shifter_cat @Anarcho_SRC @RobDye1960 @espiers Why? Because all major defenses of abortion also justify infanticide. Any logically consistent person will see this. https://t.co/h9xfAfkRcD
@Prolife_Sam "If abortion, then infanticide." Abortion entails the logical permissibility of infanticide of born infants. https://t.co/h9xfAfkRcD
@Poopshit__ @DoomSperg @Newnameel 😌 It literally is a logical consequence of your position. Since you wanted to read actual scholarly papers, here's one. https://t.co/h9xfAfD0qL
@econpoliprovida @WickAbortions @varbmos @secularprolife Not a lot of pro-abortion folks on twitter know that all personhood arguments for abortion also justify infanticide of born infants. Or that all major defenses of abortion also justify infanticide. h
@notlloomer81 @John_Reddick @HierBeforeTheAC All major defenses of abortion also justify infanticide of born infants. https://t.co/h9xfAfkRcD Why do you think you have leading pro-abortion advocates who defend infanticide as a logical consequence of their
@pixelprotectors "If abortion, then infanticide." - D. B. Hershenov. https://t.co/h9xfAfkRcD
@MelJonesladadee @jacelala @MollyBrown28 @dennymishler @AmyNoMiddleNam3 @FrCoughlinFan @ThatOneZoomer15 “If we are right that infanticide is not justified, then such arguments will fail to justify abortion.” https://t.co/olwYRS57aZ
RT @pencil_case1: 1-https://t.co/6W51S8QFk5 De hecho con los mismos argumentos con los que se legaliza el aborto se podria legalizar el in…
RT @PeacefulConserv: “if such arguments justify abortion, then they also justify infanticide. If we are right that infanticide is not justi…
RT @PeacefulConserv: “if such arguments justify abortion, then they also justify infanticide. If we are right that infanticide is not justi…
“if such arguments justify abortion, then they also justify infanticide. If we are right that infanticide is not justified, then such arguments will fail to justify abortion” https://t.co/olwYRS57aZ
RT @giuli_cavaliere: No, please, not again... https://t.co/TTAX6TBeuL
RT @JME_BMJ: If Abortion, then Infanticide https://t.co/i0iYmIo5ep https://t.co/hSUngrtf2P
No, please, not again... https://t.co/TTAX6TBeuL
RT @briandavidearp: If Abortion, then Infanticide https://t.co/FkGY5EV3X7 https://t.co/8DwTOaEJbN
If Abortion, then Infanticide https://t.co/FkGY5EV3X7 https://t.co/8DwTOaEJbN
RT @JME_BMJ: If Abortion, then Infanticide https://t.co/i0iYmIo5ep https://t.co/hSUngrtf2P
If Abortion, then Infanticide https://t.co/i0iYmIo5ep https://t.co/hSUngrtf2P
RT @CMFethics: PRJ: Arguments for #abortion 'also arguments for permitting infanticide'-people are wronged https://t.co/2tkKGzgYik @spucpr…
PRJ: Arguments for #abortion 'also arguments for permitting infanticide'-people are wronged https://t.co/2tkKGzgYik @spucprolife @bioedge
It's back. It's like pet cemetery, but infinitely worse. #bioethics https://t.co/ZY1FYD3kFJ