@jaredkavan " ....peculiar to one culture in one time (at least in its strongest form. honestly, while i respect the contribution of blanchard, i think moser, nuttbrock and people who have tried to replicate the result have shown at least some grey overla
Some supporting scholarly articles (not written by Blanchard): https://t.co/CKnGvQrMW5 https://t.co/YYTo5EiFzO
@Lulu99169723 @Sphyrna115330 @komischeemily Fetischismus findet sich häufig bei heterosexuellen transidenten Männern, als "Translesben", bei homosexuellen transidenten Männern, also Transfrauen die als Partner einen Mann suchen, weniger.⬇️ https://t.co/DHB
@TheGAndP @SloaneFragment Literally the main distinction is homosexual vs. non- homosexual. https://t.co/vgdLpUCvFt
@NomadicQuantum @profjmb @DanSmithwi78443 here's a paper that has discussion about autogynephilia in adolescence https://t.co/WfewLoYSRe
@izzie_kathryn2 @CatQQShadow @HPluckrose For example: https://t.co/v5toL5ATTl
@lulusolomo86641 I'm starting to look at this on a scale. Even homosexuals can have gynephilic tendencies. True bisexuals more so, and then of course heterosexuals more. This is strictly to do with transvetic fetishism but obviously AGP's can be such wit
@CelataAeterna @UneInvisible @WritesMyranda @xpexan33823 @peacefreak_sa @L__G__B "Twelve percent of the homosexuals reported lifecourse persistent transvestic fetishism compared to 69.0%, 44.8%, and 33.3% among the heterosexuals, bisexuals, and asexuals, r
@BonzillaG @RadioFreeStPaul @RebeccaAVelo Study based upon Blanchard's hypothesis of 571 transwomen shows consistency in the hypothesis. https://t.co/bWHMlpC9Yf
@MrCokoko @WomanWhoSaysNo @KatyMontgomerie It’s not only that he defined categories and placed irrelevant types onto them, it’s also found their data is not replicable beyond anything considered, sans age group(makes sense), he was literally just placing a
@TruthShepherrd @DrKMKandil Most of them want to be with women and often end up settling for other trans identified men because most women aren't interested. This explains. https://t.co/MadLuGyLiw
@Kaya_Nicole_02 @Aja02537920 @soberiiromione In 1982 Kurt Freund was able to link sexual arousal with cross dressing in men by using penile plethysmography. https://t.co/J0pC8UIgui In 2009 researchers were able to replicate Blanchard's findings on 571 "t
A Further Assessment of Blanchard’s Typology of Homosexual Versus Non-Homosexual or Autogynephilic Gender Dysphoria - PMC https://t.co/Nd72ETgHd2
@CharlesNegy @fentasyl I’m only speaking about the US. To start: “Compared to White MTFs, Blacks and Hispanic MTFs are more likely to report sex with biological males and endorse a homosexual identity (Hwahng&Nuttbrock, 2007).” https://t.co/0FtIHi0Ek7
@FreyaLee5806 Okay they didn’t block me just protected 🫠 I was kind of catty at first with them but here’s the study and @Invisible_TSW linked a different later in regards to sexuality and seems to debunk it but it’s just one study(pool size matters and l
@mapIechai A research team in New York City were able to replicate Blanchard's findings in 2009 by using 571 trans women. https://t.co/AXdnnZUwYr
A Further Assessment of Blanchard’s Typology of Homosexual Versus Non-Homosexual or Autogynephilic Gender Dysphoria - PMC https://t.co/Nd72ETgHd2
L Nuttbrock, W Bockting, M Mason, S Hwahng, A Rosenblum, M Macri and J Becker, 2011. A further assessment of Blanchard's typology of homosexual versus non-homosexual or autogynephilic gender dysphoria. Archives of sexual behavior, 40(2):247–257. https://t.
@natalyadell @herefortoday_ More likely to be Autogynephilic https://t.co/Nd72ETgHd2
@TeeganTandP @Invisible_TSW Theres a study on the transvestic fetishist aspect to AGP decreasing with younger generations as social awareness of homo/transsexuality increases(less stigma). Iirc it went down with those that transition, tho few sexologists p
@KXPriestess @TullipR Blanchard's methods and findings were replicated in 2009 with 571 transwomen. https://t.co/KhkxKrCjBJ
@izzie_kathryn2 @HollyGrayle You're also ignoring other contemporary and current researchers of autogynephilia: J. Michael Bailey, Anne Lawrence, Larry Nuttbrock, Walter Bockting, Mona Mason, Sel H Wahng, Andrew Rosenblum, Monica Macri, Jeffrey Becker...
@shadexana6 @N_u_l_l________ @the_nerd_skull also how about this https://t.co/2MiJFqrH3x
@ErinGratzy @jessdkant @seleonard310 @christapeterso Also, both backed up by data in follow-up studies that looked at ethnicity and age in addition to trying and failing to reproduce Blanchard's data. Here's two links for further reading: https://t.co/Ej
@EvaSilvertant @TheMilkBarTV @mostlyOatie @jordanbpeterson The 73% figure for non-homosexuals experiencing cross-gender arousal, doesn't come from a Blanchard study but a study by Nuttbrock et al (2011): https://t.co/j6btzeEvRg
@tpwrtrmnky @jball1989 @lolathepug1 @wrappinitup2 @nichole_null Where is this in the evaluation? The attractiveness of the person according to the researcher...not here. So where are you getting this from? https://t.co/FtsEMA6LzZ
@browowoward The brains of trans people vary based on etiology. Homosexual transsexual brains reflect sexual orientation. AGP brains look like heterosexual male brains. https://t.co/t14vOp4EaN Blanchard's methodology was reaffirmed in 2009 on 571 transwo
RT @Brenmco: @nick_the_geek78 Here is one study you might find interesting: https://t.co/VBNj6EmVco
@KaSyl_Town Here's one conducted by people who positioned themselves as Blanchard's ideological opponents. https://t.co/7hlfxpdcBU Notice how similar the bars are? Blanchard's typology has been replicated. https://t.co/bI6eehz0na
@KirstieMAllsopp Here’s a peer reviewed study. real data. I really can’t believe your attitude around this. 75% autogynaphillia! It’s a fetish, same as a yur floral flouncy dresses! It’s all good, but context & safety comes first @jk_rowling @sharron
RT @DerekPederson3: Literally every "critique" of Blanchard: proposes a theory that is virtually identical to that of Blanchard. https://t.…
Literally every "critique" of Blanchard: proposes a theory that is virtually identical to that of Blanchard. https://t.co/IXfHBopOjK https://t.co/U9QrMDDBMN
@NeuroSGS This paper replicated Blanchard's 1985 typology findings, lending further weight to the two-type typology: https://t.co/z5yXLmg9p4
@KendraIzzy @lourob2 @KatyMontgomerie So basically the trans “lesbians” and they get to tell lesbians they’re transphobic for not wanting to date them. I’d say that’s kind of homophobic. You just haven’t had “girl d*ck” https://t.co/Rw8bCyPK8f
@Display_Geek @EliyaXue @rosykaren @rachelisblue @nytopinion Yes! And that's why I have serious concerns about the validity of your claims! After all, Blanchard had to retract his assertions after methodological problems and lack of reproducibility were no
@Display_Geek @EliyaXue @rosykaren @rachelisblue @nytopinion Furthermore, most of your work comes from the now discredited works of Blanchard who later retracted his entire thesis due to severe conflicts of interest. https://t.co/v2XbNcRS4O Its systemic pr
@Hypercortical https://t.co/Hxp1z7mSI0 From 2011
@DunkedHobnobs @Iamthisnotthat1 Blanchard found a small cohort of gay men for whom the desire to "become a woman" went beyond classic HSTS dysphoria & into "transvestic fetishism". It's more rare than among het trans males but even studies somewhat hos
@OttoKummerspeck @OuroborosSouth @GraveInformer @Brocklesnitch And the evidence for the original paper is even more dubious assuming the people who didn't match were just lying about their experiences is just bad science. https://t.co/eECs3z6kmz
@lecanardnoir @Tintern_Film @Unity_MoT @EddieIzzardLab And, of course, Dr. Ray Blanchard's research which originated the term, discussed in this recent paper. https://t.co/qPDteaXyaD
@mute__spectre @wil_da_beast630 @terfforever Typology - 73% heterosexual MTF; average age of transition is 39, AGP dominates here 23% homosexual MTF- younger, feminine from birth, ‘passing’ before HRT - the ‘brain studies’ to entrench gender as biology is
@mute__spectre @wil_da_beast630 @terfforever Which is 90% of the MTF population. https://t.co/lTgRSlGEQ6
@yawn_really @ricaus77 @lisasevern @NationalNOW If you read critically & broadly, you would know that Blanchard's findings have been widely critiqued. Let's start with non-replication. https://t.co/JjQF9U4xYy
@SocialistWine @BluffKingHal The number of sames sex attracted TIMs, HSTS, is lower than the number of TIMs who are attracted to women. https://t.co/TeYk3dWopa https://t.co/VJazZnWxkc
@nick_the_geek78 Here is one study you might find interesting: https://t.co/VBNj6EmVco
@GrabbedGremlin @correctrix @halomancer1 @lacroicsz Self ID is useless. Better is measured arousal https://t.co/kutY3FnbY2 Words like queer and pansexual are so loose and silly, they don't tell us how often people actually have sex with men or women or ho
AGP arousal study by Blanchard. https://t.co/41ggWXZsAC
@elegationvain @grass_pale @emkayohkay @GrannyHawthorn @FKASerioJosh @BlanchardPhD Fascinating paper here that found transvestic fetishism in all orientations By its very definition the word agp seems impossible to apply to a gay cohort though? https://t
@HylianApologist @Cathemerality @bernieistired @cbucksrules @TERFBunker There is a second typology, but they are the minority. Many AGPs either don't understand what they're experiencing or lie about it, but arousal can be measured in a lab. https://t.co/g
@nyabused Kkkk, então refute esses artigos https://t.co/aCr2GVvICY https://t.co/YISuChNtkh https://t.co/piuibHbwIE https://t.co/Si3jOH6rvy Agp
https://t.co/QnoOYKfkHs *The paper points out problems with Blanchard’s work*! LMAO they can’t even be bothered to put effort into their bigotry!
@Zombiecat_Luna @ClownfishAgain @miriammirwitch You've been given the proof repeatedly, you just refuse to accept it. https://t.co/8gjDwBufS5
4 …almost no one is a Freudian any more. His views didn’t wash. I think the Blanchard typology https://t.co/LLGV8g7kC1 will go that way. There is a correlation between the physical sex/genitalia one needs and orientation, but…
A lot of trans people, more at transgender people, are worried about Blanchard typology, Bailey, Lawrence…autogynephilia, etc., https://t.co/LLGV8g7kC1 But I’m an old former psychotherapist, and I think fear of it is overdone. Let me show show you why a
@_FelineMenace @notCursedE @minusplnp @climate_holly But not ones sex. You have not linked to any studies, merely listed them, with no description about what any of them are about.I'm not here to do your work for you. https://t.co/Y1hhZBGKCQ
@KittyKait69 @c_a_t_t_o @radicaldreamr_ Here's a 2011 study of 571 subjects that verifies key aspects of Blanchard's findings: https://t.co/35Yv6NkFYu And no, I will not watch a YouTube video by an ideological figurehead as a substitute for scientific ar
@lecanardnoir @Paul_R50 @hero0foakvale @hannahthinkss >AGP is not scientifically controversial https://t.co/aTLZLGxcUp https://t.co/2bvELxTp4t https://t.co/Bpw3yaOKa5 https://t.co/T0L45fmz3y
@Chr1stinaG @KatyMontgomerie Blanchard's: https://t.co/Rlv773tZcb Nuttbrock's: https://t.co/vUOvufEtmr Worth noting that Nuttbrock is a critic of Blanchard, so he ofc. hasn't "engineered" the study to give a high result.
@ViralHatred @EllieTheScience @PrawnoftheP @transwidows @DavidRi73368620 @AGPAwarenessDay around 20% of self-reporting exclusively-androphilic MtFs. See e.g. Nuttbrock as one example: https://t.co/vUOvufEtmr
RT @bloominanna: No. It is only a small % of vocal narcissistic AGP activists who deny autogynephilia and attempt to control how they are…
No. It is only a small % of vocal narcissistic AGP activists who deny autogynephilia and attempt to control how they are perceived. However 82% of gynephilic trans identified males acknowledge being autogynephilic https://t.co/Qb3HOtan4g https://t.co/
https://t.co/vdxS7KX0Pz good read on attempts to duplicate some of Blanchard's research conclusions on homosexual and non-homosexual MtFs
@tailcalled @lilliankodi @TheWolfSpirit1 Here are ALL the papers you've cited: https://t.co/TOcDKFlDJQ https://t.co/PiH8YRvwmw All of them. And I responded to both of them.
@ImplausibleGrrl @lilliankodi @TheWolfSpirit1 And by "contradicting almost all other research on the topic", I'm including research by other critics of Blanchard, e.g. Nuttbrock. https://t.co/vUOvufEtmr
@9BillionTigers @arthur_affect Here is what I got in a survey. Similarly, even AGP skeptics like Nuttbrock find high rates. https://t.co/vUOvufEtmr https://t.co/R6LkYPWxkm
@AGPTranswoman @MavenOfMayhem @324_B21 Latter finding is discussed here https://t.co/4YN4DUDhQP
@lucky_pez @FrankMankiewicz @Eric_Cochran @bethanyshondark It's not subjective, that's the point of the science, at least, the peer reviewed science. https://t.co/4xUh7367uY https://t.co/QAXHljzYfP
@Lyncei @ContraPoints even among trans women it's not limited to lesbians like Blanchard thought (cw - this study is cold + dehumanising) https://t.co/36w0w0IXV5
21世紀のニューヨーク市では、MtFのなかの女装フェチ(BATにおけるnon-homosexual MtFの典型)が著しく少子高齢化した https://t.co/lZAZuajD5C
But widespread among all ages and ethnicities: https://t.co/oq3qdiGb3d https://t.co/XfRbhvHg9u